PilotTalk: Cops and Journalists in PRC and Taiwan TV
Jan 11, 2024
auto_awesome
Ben Smith, editor-in-chief of Semafor, joins to discuss Chinese and Taiwanese TV shows. Topics include crime dramas, police portrayals, media sensationalism, treatment of mental illness, and the role of journalism in democracy.
The Chinese TV show Ordinary Greatness provides a balanced portrayal of Chinese police culture while incorporating familiar genre conventions.
The Taiwanese drama series The World Between Us explores the complex dynamics within a newsroom and the ethical dilemmas journalists face.
Deep dives
Cop Show: Ordinary Greatness
The podcast discusses an episode of a Chinese cop show called Ordinary Greatness. The show follows the daily lives of police officers in a small city police station. It explores the dynamics and relationships among the characters with various backgrounds. The show combines elements of workplace drama and police procedural, maintaining a balance between familiar genre conventions and unfamiliar aspects of Chinese police culture.
Journalism Drama: The World Between Us
The podcast highlights a Taiwanese drama series called The World Between Us. The show revolves around a devastating school shooting and the coverage of the case by a journalist. It delves into the internal struggles of the characters, their personal lives, and the ethical dilemmas they face. The series presents a nuanced portrayal of journalism and explores the complex dynamics within the newsroom, including the intense competition and the race for ratings.
Government Workers and Media Relations
The podcast touches upon the portrayal of government workers and their relationship with the media in Chinese TV shows. It discusses the expectation that media should portray government agencies positively and how the distortion or misinterpretation of news can create conflicts. The podcast highlights the differences in media norms and social responsibilities between Western and Chinese societies. Additionally, it explores the cultural and societal factors that influence the treatment of media and its role in shaping public perception.
Sentimental Romantic Drama: A Date with the Future
The podcast mentions a romantic drama series called A Date with the Future. The show revolves around a firefighter who falls in love with a journalist. It explores their relationship, the challenges they face, and their personal growth. The series also delves into the ambivalence towards journalism, highlighting the pressures of balancing personal and professional lives. It portrays media coverage and the consequences of social media distortions on the work of journalists.
New year, new PilotTalk! Ben Smith, editor-in-chief of Semafor, joins Jordan and editor Irene to watch Chinese and Taiwanese TV shows. Ben’s favorite genre is crime and police dramas, and we cover the following new-ish releases:
A Date With The Future 照亮你 (2023, mainland): Romance where a firefighter falls in love with a journalist!
The World Between Us 我們與惡的距離 (2019, Taiwan): Acclaimed miniseries set in the aftermath of a mass shooting, addressing media sensationalism, treatment of the mentally ill, and the death penalty.
Outtro music: Kiss Me by Taiwanese artist Karencici https://open.spotify.com/track/7HZmJLWtISxYnoBqwx04bw?si=896165f1b52a4aa0