Being Human Episode 250: Correcting Luther and…Aquinas? Calling Out Disintegration in the Church Dating Back to the Reformation
Oct 28, 2025
This discussion highlights the alarming trend of disintegration within the Church, echoing Martin Luther's initial break. Dr. Greg critiques outdated theological concepts, especially from Aquinas, that misrepresent femininity and masculinity. He stresses the importance of unity and doctrinal development, emphasizing the relevance of John Paul II's personalism. The podcast also calls for a reassessment of traditional views leading to societal harm and advocates for modern integration within Catholic teachings. The dialogue pushes for a unified approach without repeating past mistakes.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Disintegration Versus Integration
- Disintegration in the Church repeats Luther's core error of choosing either/or over both/and when facing scandal and complexity.
- Greg Bottaro urges unity under apostolic succession while calling out legitimate reforms without leaving communion.
Both/And Over Either/Or
- Humans prefer simple either/or answers to complex mysteries because of cognitive shortcuts like cognitive dissonance.
- Bottaro frames faithful theology as a ‘both/and’ integration that resists arrested spiritual development.
Restore Sacraments And Relationship
- Reclaim the sacraments and the personal relationship with Jesus as complementary needs in ecumenical dialogue.
- Catholics should invite Protestants back for sacraments while Catholics recover a vibrant relationship with Christ.
