In this insightful discussion, political reporter Amy Remeikis teams up with host Nour Haydar to dissect the recent controversies surrounding the Australian census. They delve into Labor's backtracking on gender identity questions, revealing the urgency for inclusivity. Remeikis uncovers the internal backlash within the Labor party and the risks of alienating supporters amid culture wars. The conversation highlights how these decisions impact the LGBTQ+ community and the potential for policy invisibility, sparking a critical dialogue on representation.
The exclusion of LGBTQ+ questions in the census underscores significant shortcomings in resource allocation and representation for these communities.
Labor's indecision on including gender identity questions illustrates the party's struggle to balance internal dissent and external cultural sensitivities.
Deep dives
LGBTQ+ Exclusion in the Census
The absence of questions regarding sexual orientation and gender identity in the Australian census has long been a point of contention among LGBTQ+ advocates. This exclusion affects the government's ability to accurately allocate health resources and implement programs that address disparities faced by these communities. A notable incident involved a Newcastle parent, April Long, who filed a complaint in 2022 after feeling marginalized due to the lack of inclusive questions in the census. This led to the Australian Bureau of Statistics acknowledging the oversight but ultimately, the Labor government backtracked on plans to rectify it, creating frustration among those advocating for proper representation.
Government's Cultural Conundrum
The government's abrupt decision to scrap proposed inclusion of LGBTQ+ questions was perceived as an attempt to sidestep potential divisive debates within the community. Deputy Prime Minister Richard Miles indicated a desire to maintain social harmony, implying that asking about these identities could stir contention. However, this perspective has drawn criticism as it dismisses the existence and importance of varying gender identities and sexual orientations. The situation has led to a broader conversation about the government's hesitance to engage with social issues and the underlying fears of facing cultural backlash in a politically sensitive landscape.
Internal Backlash and Political Implications
Following the government’s controversial decision, there was a significant internal backlash from Labor backbenchers who felt uncomfortable with the exclusionary move. Several members publicly voiced their concerns, emphasizing the importance of inclusivity and the need for the census to reflect the diverse identities within Australia. This discontent signals potential risks for the Labor party, suggesting that their approach may alienate progressive voters while failing to appease conservative ones. As various factions within the party grapple with the fallout, there is a growing concern that the avoidance of culturally sensitive topics could jeopardize their standing in upcoming elections.
LGBTQ+ advocates were hopeful the 2026 census would include new questions on gender identity after the Labor party committed to do so. But last week news broke that the government ditched that plan. Then it backtracked days later to include one question after all. But many say the move doesn’t go far enough. Political reporter Amy Remeikis tells Nour Haydar why Labor is jumping at culture war shadows You can support the Guardian at theguardian.com/fullstorysupport
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode