Enlightenment ideals aren't working | Jonathan Pageau | EP41
Jun 13, 2024
auto_awesome
In this engaging discussion, Jonathan Pageau, a French Canadian icon carver, public speaker, and YouTuber, explores the limits of Enlightenment ideals. He critiques the disconnect in modern society and advocates for a resurgence of religious meaning, suggesting that Christianity can provide much-needed cohesion. The conversation delves into the tensions between secularism and spirituality, the complexities of discerning genuine faith, and the interplay of reason and the mysteries of existence. Pageau's insights challenge listeners to rethink identity and belief systems.
The Enlightenment's focus on reason neglects the significance of mystery and non-rational aspects of human experience, leading to societal chaos.
Revisiting religious narratives and principles can provide individuals with communal values and meaning in an increasingly fragmented contemporary society.
Deep dives
The Search for Meaning in Modern Society
There is a growing realization that despite advancements in material wealth and comfort due to enlightenment and scientific progress, many people feel an absence of meaning and purpose in their lives. This quest for significance highlights the need for a deeper connection to religious stories and mythologies that have historically provided a framework for understanding existence. By revisiting these narratives, individuals can explore essential questions about why they seek purpose and how these ancient structures can reunite them with a sense of community and cohesion. The importance of these stories lies in their ability to guide people towards finding personal and collective meaning in an increasingly fragmented world.
The Inevitability of Religious Participation
In contemporary discourse, there is a shift towards acknowledging that rationalist enlightenment ideas alone cannot sustain societal cohesion, and as a result, diverse forms of religiosity are re-emerging. This resurgence ranges from traditional religions to new age beliefs, and even ideological movements like environmentalism and 'wokeness.' The underlying theme of seeking purpose compels individuals to affiliate with religious-like structures, celebrating what they consider sacred. The question now becomes what beliefs or ideologies will dominate this newfound religious expression as society grapples with its fragmented identity.
Critique of Enlightenment Rationalism
The Enlightenment is often praised for its emphasis on reason, yet a critical examination reveals that this perspective inherently overlooks the importance of mystery and the transcendent aspects of existence. This singular focus on rationality can lead to a blind spot regarding the non-rational elements of human experience, such as emotions, identities, and the complexities of existence. When reason is idolized, it can devolve into chaos, as passions and irrational desires take over, exemplified by societal phenomena that seem illogical from a purely rational standpoint. Recognizing the limitations of reason is crucial for understanding the complexities of identity and the inherent contradictions in contemporary discourse.
The Path Forward: Embracing the Spiritual and the Traditional
A return to a foundational understanding of Christianity is proposed as a means to navigate the challenges posed by a disenchanted secularism. While the future may not see a resurgence of Christendom, a deeper engagement with Christian principles can foster communal values and ethical frameworks necessary for societal cohesion. Balancing reason with the intuitive elements of mystery can provide a holistic approach to understanding human experience, transcending mere rational argumentation. This engagement encourages individuals to participate in their communities and traditions as a way to cultivate personal and collective meaning amidst the chaos of modern life.
Jonathan Pageau is a French Canadian icon carver, public speaker and YouTuber exploring the symbolic patterns that underlie our experience of the world. Luke and Jonathan discuss Jonathan's disagreements with James Lindsay on issues like the enlightenment and the place of religion in society.
Disagree with Jonathan? Let us know in the YouTube comments!