Samuel Clowes Huneke, "A Queer Theory of the State" (Floating Opera Press, 2023)
Nov 27, 2023
auto_awesome
Guest Samuel Clowes Huneke discusses his book 'A Queer Theory of the State' and explores bridging queer theory with the practicalities of the state. They delve into themes of gender, sexuality, legal history, and democracy. Huneke examines the influence of history and German culture on queer theory, discussing their experiences studying history, German, and influences like Klaus Manton. They explore the tension of normativity in queer theory and politics, critiques of progress made with initiatives like marriage equality, and skepticism of universality. The role of pragmatism in queer theory and politics is examined, along with the potential for working with the state to challenge oppressive norms and create political progress. Huneke also discusses their current research project on queer women in Nazi Germany.
Queer theory can embrace political engagement by bridging anti-normative perspectives with the pragmatic need for the state.
Queer theory can contribute to reimagining power dynamics and fostering a more robust left in contemporary politics.
Deep dives
Queer theory's hesitation towards aligning with the politics of the state
The podcast episode features Samuel Cluse-Unikey discussing his book, A Queer Theory of the State. He explores how queer theory has historically been reluctant to align with the politics of the state due to viewing the state as an enemy of queer people and considering it insignificant in advancing queer politics. However, Cluse-Unikey offers a more optimistic perspective, arguing for the need to bridge historically anti-normative queer perspectives with the pragmatic need for the state. He highlights the importance of critiquing norms and power structures while acknowledging the potential for positive change within the state.
The personal and academic journey towards queer theory
Cluse-Unikey shares his personal and academic journey into queer theory. As a historian, his interest in history and German studies led him to explore the history of gender and sexuality, particularly in relation to modern Germany. His own identity as a gay man also played a role in his exploration of queer theory. He discusses the influence of queer authors such as Klaus Manton and the impact of Michel Foucault's work on his understanding of power dynamics and norms. Cluse-Unikey's research on queer history in Germany, including his first book, States of Liberation, further shaped his perspective on queer theory and motivated him to write A Queer Theory of the State.
The critique of queer theory's lack of a theory of the state
Cluse-Unikey critiques queer theory for its lack of a comprehensive theory of the state, rooted in the perception of the state as an inherent enemy of queer people and a belief that the state is not significant in advancing queer politics. He highlights how queer theory traditionally focuses on critiquing norms and identities rather than engaging with the state as a site of political activism. He references the work of scholars like Lisa Duggan, who argue for the potential of queer theory in shaping positive political change, and the need to balance critique with practical approaches to dismantling oppressive norms and achieving progress within the state.
Towards a queer form of democracy and reenchanting progressivism
Cluse-Unikey explores the concept of a queer form of democracy and the need for reenchanting progressivism. By challenging traditional notions of democracy rooted in individual sovereignty, he suggests embracing the communitarian and interconnected nature of queer identities and relationships. He also draws on the works of scholars like Evern Sava and Walter Benjamin to argue for the importance of feminist and queer joy, belief in the commons, and a reimagining of power dynamics within a queer political framework. Cluse-Unikey believes that his book can contribute to fostering a more robust left and reenchanting progressivism in contemporary politics.
Queer theory has often been hesitant to align itself with a politics of the state, approaching it with a negative or pragmatic framework.A Queer Theory of the State (Floating Opera Press, 2023) expands an earlier online essay from The Point by historian Samuel Huneke to offer a more optimistic perspective. Rather than eschew political engagement with democratic theorizing, Huneke asks how queer theory can wed its critically anti-normative impulses to the empirical need for a state. In answering this question, Huneke shows how the state is an integral component of a politics that seeks to subvert and undo the oppression of queer lives.
Lea Greenberg is an editor, translator, and scholar of German and Jewish studies.