The Brainy Business | Understanding the Psychology of Why People Buy | Behavioral Economics

286. Beyond 'If Only': Maximizing the Benefits of Counterfactual Thinking (Refreshed Episode)

May 9, 2023

Ask episode

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

Counterfactual thinking (when we mentally "undo" events that have already happened and imagine different outcomes) can contribute to personal and professional growth when applied constructively. This type of thinking is closely related to prefactual thinking, which involves imagining future scenarios, alternatives, and opportunities. Both types of thinking can aid in regulating behavior, problem-solving, and goal setting, ultimately contributing to improved performance and success in life and business.

This episode highlights the interplay between counterfactual and prefactual thinking and how both can foster unique perspectives and considerations that set individuals and businesses apart from the competition. There is immense value in adopting a curious, open-minded approach when engaging in these thought processes, which can ultimately lead to personal development, innovation, and cultivating a successful and resilient mindset. Here's some of what you'll get from this episode:

Explore the intriguing effects of counterfactual thinking on emotions and behaviors.
Identify the fine line between helpful and detrimental counterfactual thoughts.
Learn effective tactics for managing counterfactual thinking in tough situations.
Uncover the power of combining counterfactual and prefactual thinking for a winning strategy.
Master transforming negativity into productive and positive actions.

Show Notes:

00:00:00 - Introduction, Melina Palmer introduces the podcast episode (a refresh from one that originally aired in October 2019) focusing on counterfactual thinking and how it is central to being human. She explains the different types of counterfactuals and the impact they can have on our emotions and way of thinking.
00:05:06 - Types of Counterfactuals, Melina explains the difference between upward and downward counterfactuals, omissions and commissions, rumination and undoing, and usual or extreme events. She encourages listeners to reflect on their own types of counterfactuals and how they have impacted them in the past.
00:09:25 - Target of Counterfactuals, Melina discusses how the target of counterfactuals can impact the thought process. She gives an example of how people tend to focus on themselves even when they are not to blame, which can lead to distress and anxiety.
00:13:32 - Example of Unhealthy Counterfactual Thinking, Melina provides an extreme example of unhealthy counterfactual thinking where a woman dwells over a nonevent at work and becomes distressed and angry, constantly dwelling over what the woman in HR did or didn't do and how she could have acted differently.
00:14:50 - Recap, Melina summarizes the key takeaways from the episode so far and encourages listeners to use counterfactual thinking as a tool for setting and achieving goals, while also being mindful of when it becomes unhealthy and causes distress. She reminds listeners to download the free counterfactual thinking worksheet (and get more resources) in the show notes.
00:14:57 - The Impact of Counterfactual Thinking, Counterfactual thinking can lead to spiraling thoughts and negatively impact interactions. Dwelling on negatives can be harmful and counterproductive. It's essential to focus on the present and not dwell on the past.
00:19:07 - A Study on Counterfactual Thinking, A study on counterfactual thinking found that over half of the respondents were undoing a traumatic event in their minds. The distress level and frequency of undoing did not differ based on whether the item being undone was usual or exceptional; omission or commission.
00:25:31 - Focus on Self, Those who were undoing the event in their minds were more focused on their own actions or the actions of their loved ones than the other driver's behavior, even though the other driver was (typically) at fault. This shows how quickly the brain can compartmentalize and can lead to feelings of regret, guilt, and responsibility.
00:28:54 - Recency of Undoing, The recency of the undoing process (note: this is not the recency of the event) impacted distress levels. Those who were still undoing the event were more distressed than those who had never undone or had undone in the past, but stopped. This suggests that undoing may be a distress-driven cognitive process.
00:31:15 - Changing Focus, The action that people actively undo overwhelmingly changes over time. People may focus on themselves and their actions in a particular circumstance, but the specific action that they focus on can vary. The lesson is to focus on the present and not dwell on the past.
00:31:47 - The Effects of Undoing, Continuously undoing can increase distress levels, and guilt is the only negative emotion uniquely related to undoing. Guilt related to controllable events declines over time, but excessive undoing can perpetuate distress.
00:33:21 - Self Esteem and Counterfactual Thinking, People with low self-esteem may focus on their inadequacies in their counterfactuals, leading to more distress. Highly distressed individuals undo more frequently, perpetuating their distress.
00:35:09 - The Benefits of Counterfactual Thinking, Counterfactual thinking is crucial in regulating behavior and reaching goals. Failing to reach a goal often leads to counterfactual thinking, but reframing it can improve behavior. Turning counterfactual thoughts into actionable next steps can help reach goals. Plus, the one, most important phrase to help you leverage counterfactual thinking and use it to your advantage.
00:38:37 - Moving Forward from Counterfactual Thinking, Moving on from counterfactual thinking is crucial to prevent it from taking over your life and work. Asking questions like, "What can I do differently next time?" can help reframe counterfactual thoughts into positive next steps. An example from the Olympics, and how to use that most powerful language.
00:41:25 - Positive Thinking, Reframing, and a Refreshed Close, Acting as if you were a silver-lining person can trick your brain into thinking that way. Mental reframes and curious questions can change everything and set you and your business apart. Consider how different things might be if you flipped your counterfactual thinking around.

Thanks for listening. Don’t forget to subscribe on Apple Podcasts or Android. If you like what you heard, please leave a review on iTunes and share what you liked about the show.

I hope you love everything recommended via The Brainy Business! Everything was independently reviewed and selected by me, Melina Palmer. So you know, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. That means if you decide to shop from the links on this page (via Amazon or others), The Brainy Business may collect a share of sales or other compensation.

Let’s connect:

Melina@TheBrainyBusiness.com
The Brainy Business® on Facebook
The Brainy Business on Twitter
The Brainy Business on Instagram
The Brainy Business on LinkedIn
Melina on LinkedIn
The Brainy Business on Youtube
Join the BE Thoughtful Revolution – our free behavioral economics community, and keep the conversation going!