Ainslie Johnstone and Sacha Nauta from The Economist, along with Professor Musa al-Gharbi, delve into the decline of wokeness in America. They discuss how societal attitudes towards issues like race and privilege have shifted, marking a significant change from peak wokeness in 2021-22. The conversation analyzes the rise of anti-woke sentiments and their implications for future political dynamics. They also reflect on the historical context of social movements, emphasizing the importance of free speech in today’s polarized climate.
The peak of wokeness between 2021 and 2022 has receded, reflecting a shift towards more moderate Democratic rhetoric on social issues.
The backlash against 'woke' ideals signifies a complex dialogue in American identity politics, with implications for future electoral outcomes and generational changes.
Deep dives
Carmen Quiroga's Cafe and Wokeness Controversy
Carmen Quiroga opened a breakfast cafe called 'Woke Breakfast and Coffee' in Coventry, Connecticut, intending to create a welcoming, breakfast-themed atmosphere. The name, however, led to backlash from local conservatives who interpreted it as a political statement, prompting threats of a boycott. Quiroga, having immigrated from Mexico, was unaware that the term 'woke' had taken on significant political implications in the U.S. Despite the controversy, the community mostly supported her new venture, and locals can still enjoy their meals without avoiding the fraught political connotations of the name.
The Decline of Wokeness in American Politics
Over the past decade, a type of wokeness characterized by a pessimistic view of America's progress on issues of race emerged, peaking between 2021 and 2022. However, recent analysis indicates that interest in these ideas has begun to wane, leading to questions about what follows this peak. The decline in woke sentiment coincides with political shifts, particularly within the Democratic Party, where rhetoric has become more moderate, reflecting a recognition that extreme views may hinder electoral success. This shift opens a dialogue on the re-emergence of common ground and less divisive approaches to discussing inequities.
Data Analysis of Wokeness Trends
A detailed examination of public opinion regarding wokeness through surveys and data revealed that views saw a notable rise from 2015 to around 2021, followed by a decline as awareness shifted. Analysis of media usage around 'woke' terminology, comparing major publications, indicated a similar trend: an initial spike in usage beginning in 2015, which peaked around 2019 but has since significantly receded. Additionally, the corporate world experienced a temporary surge in diversity and inclusion initiatives following high-profile incidents, yet these efforts appear to have receded as well. This indicates not just a cultural shift in the narrative surrounding wokeness but also substantial impacts on how it is approached in various sectors.
Political Implications of Wokeness and Anti-Wokeness
The phenomenon of wokeness has highlighted tensions within American identity politics, leading to a fierce backlash that has become politically salient among conservatives. Anti-wokeness rhetoric has gained traction, often portrayed as a necessary correction to perceived excesses, but this charge is also noted for its political utility in rallying support. This complex dynamic raises questions about the future direction of both movements, as ongoing challenges around social justice and equity continue to provoke debate. Ultimately, the future of wokeness and its counter-movement will likely be shaped significantly by upcoming electoral outcomes and generational shifts in sentiment.
Over the past decade a form of wokeness arose on the illiberal left, characterised by extreme pessimism about America and its capacity to make progress. Analysis by The Economistof how influential these ideas are today finds that wokeness peaked in 2021-22 and has since receded. Why is America becoming less “woke”?
John Prideaux hosts with Charlotte Howard and Idrees Kahloon. They’re joined by The Economist’s Ainslie Johnstone and Sacha Nauta, and Professor Musa al-Gharbi of Stony Brook University.