David Lyon, "Surveillance: A Very Short Introduction" (Oxford UP, 2024)
Jan 8, 2025
auto_awesome
David Lyon, a leading expert on surveillance and former Director of the Surveillance Studies Centre, delves into the pervasive nature of surveillance in today's society. He discusses how tech advancements, especially during the pandemic, have reshaped our understanding of privacy. Ethical concerns around facial recognition technology and its biases come to light, alongside the impacts of surveillance capitalism where corporations profit from our data. Lyon passionately argues for a critical examination of these systems, urging a call for digital citizenship and responsibility.
Surveillance has evolved to reflect a spectrum of practices, from beneficial, like wildlife monitoring, to invasive, such as facial recognition technology in transit systems.
The rise of surveillance capitalism shifts the focus from governmental oversight to corporate control, emphasizing the commodification of personal data and its ethical implications.
Deep dives
The Evolution of Surveillance
Surveillance has significantly evolved over the years, particularly with advancements in technology. David Lyon defines surveillance as a systematic activity aimed at monitoring personal details for various purposes, such as protection and management. The rise of the internet and social media since 2008 has heightened public awareness of surveillance, prompting society to rethink its implications and our roles within it. This newer understanding emphasizes that surveillance is not just an imposed system but an experience in which individuals actively participate, often without complete awareness.
The Spectrum of Surveillance
Surveillance can be viewed on a spectrum, ranging from beneficial to invasive practices. For instance, monitoring endangered wildlife is generally accepted, while comprehensive facial recognition technology raises ethical concerns. An example given in the discussion highlights Air Canada's facial recognition system for faster boarding, which ostensibly offers convenience but also poses risks related to privacy and accuracy. Such technologies demonstrate the tension between the perceived benefits and the underlying issues of data misuse and reliability.
The Impact of Smartphones
Smartphones play a pivotal role in contemporary surveillance, often viewed as symbols of personal tracking. With users carrying these devices constantly, data collection occurs seamlessly through apps and services we engage with. During the pandemic, the Canadian Public Health Agency utilized geolocation data from phone users to trace the spread of COVID-19, highlighting the invasive nature of such tracking. This ongoing data collection raises profound questions about privacy, autonomy, and the implications of mapping individual behaviors.
Corporate Surveillance and Human Flourishing
The rise of surveillance capitalism underscores the critical role corporations play in surveillance practices today. Shoshana Zuboff's work addresses how companies, particularly tech giants, monetize personal data, shifting the paradigm from traditional government oversight to corporate influence. This transformation has resulted in individuals becoming the products rather than mere subjects of surveillance. Lyon argues for a reconstruction of surveillance discussions, focusing on its potential to promote human flourishing through trustworthy, relational, and justice-seeking practices.
Surveillance is everywhere today, generating data about our purchasing, political, and personal preferences. Surveillance: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford University Press, 2024) shows how surveillance makes people visible and affects their lives, considers the technologies involved and how it grew to its present size and prevalence, and explores the pressing ethical questions surrounding it.
David Lyon is former Director of the Surveillance Studies Centre and Professor Emeritus of Sociology and Law, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario.