

HoP 473 As Rational As You: Elisabeth of Bohemia
Jul 6, 2025
Dive into the intellectual world of Elizabeth of Bohemia, a royal thinker who courageously debates Descartes. Discover her groundbreaking contributions to early modern philosophy and the challenges faced by women in this arena. Their letters tackle profound topics such as mind-body dualism, ethics, and the nature of happiness, revealing a fascinating clash of practical concerns versus abstract ideas. Elizabeth’s insights challenge the philosophical norms of her time, making her a true pioneer.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Elizabeth's Hidden Philosophical Dialogue
- Princess Elizabeth of Bohemia refused to publish her philosophical letters with Descartes for over 200 years.
- Her rediscovered letters reveal her as a thoughtful and critical philosopher engaging Descartes in deep dialogue.
Elizabeth's Challenge to Dualism
- Elizabeth pinpointed the problem of Cartesian dualism about how an unextended soul can move the body.
- She provocatively suggested the soul might be extended if it can affect bodily motion, challenging Descartes' views.
Descartes' Responses to Elizabeth
- Descartes offered the analogy of heaviness and allowed treating the soul as extended to explain mind-body interaction.
- These responses blur Cartesian dualism, implying intimate union though metaphysical distinctness of soul and body.