Sex, Death and Progressive Nostalgia: AKOM Talks w/ Dr. Richard Mills
Sep 3, 2024
auto_awesome
Dr. Richard Mills, Associate Professor in English Literature and Popular Culture at St Mary's University, discusses the intricate world of Beatles fandom. He delves into the transformative nature of fan interactions, from tribute bands to slash fiction. The dark side of fandom is explored, highlighting violence against celebrities like John Lennon. Mills also emphasizes the need for inclusive narratives that acknowledge female fandom and the impact of fan-created content on the band’s legacy, revealing the complexities of love, loss, and creativity within the Beatles' influence.
The Beatles' timeless appeal stems from their ability to resonate across generations, providing personal meaning to new listeners.
Fandom dynamics often polarize around prominent figures like John and Paul, obscuring the band's collaborative contributions essential to their legacy.
Artistic expressions by fans, such as fan fiction and tribute bands, play a crucial role in preserving and celebrating the Beatles' influence.
The concept of 'dark fandom' reveals complexities in the fan-celebrity relationship, highlighting deeper psychological issues beyond mere celebrity worship.
Biographical portrayals of the Beatles frequently simplify their narratives and collaborative spirit, emphasizing the need for a nuanced understanding of their legacy.
Deep dives
The Enduring Fascination with the Beatles
The conversation highlights that the Beatles continue to captivate audiences long after their initial fame, as people are consistently drawn to their music and stories. This timeless appeal stems from the band's ability to resonate with different generations, with each new listener finding personal meaning in their songs. The Beatles' image, characterized by charisma and camaraderie, contributes to their allure as a group of good-looking and humorous individuals. This enduring fascination is reinforced by the sheer quality of their music, making it universally likable and something that resonates on a personal level for fans.
The Complexity of Fandom and Elvis vs. Beatles Debate
The complexities of fandom are explored, noting how discussions often polarize around key figures like John and Paul. The Beatles' story is frequently reduced to binary comparisons, such as who was the true genius behind their success. This tendency can overshadow the collaborative nature of the band, where all members contributed significantly to their iconic status. By examining the dynamics within the band and the fandom, the conversation reflects on the narratives that have evolved and how fans have navigated these complex relationships over the years.
Fandom as a Form of Artistic Expression
Fandom is framed as a form of artistic expression that serves to keep the Beatles' memory and influence alive. Through various mediums such as fan fiction, music covers, and tribute bands, fans reinterpret and celebrate the band's legacy. This continuous reinterpretation aids in maintaining public interest and relevance, allowing contemporary audiences to engage with the Beatles' art in new ways. Such expressions not only keep the Beatles' music alive but also enrich the cultural conversation surrounding them, ensuring their legacy remains vibrant.
Exploring Dark Fandom and Celebrity Culture
The discussion ventures into the territory of dark fandom, particularly in the context of violence against celebrities like John Lennon and George Harrison. The narrative challenges the oversimplified notion of 'deranged fans,' suggesting that such behavior stems from deeper psychological issues rather than mere fandom. The concept of 'dark fandom' reflects on how celebrity worship can result in tragic outcomes, shedding light on the complexities of the fan-celebrity relationship. These reflections raise important questions about mental health, community, and the societal factors that contribute to such violent acts.
The Role of Biography in shaping the Beatles' Internal Narratives
Biographies of the Beatles are scrutinized for their ability to shape and often simplify the band's internal narratives, particularly in relation to John and Paul. The conversation emphasizes that most biographers tend to favor one Beatle over the other, skewing the portrayal and oversimplifying their contributions. This tendency can lead to a misrepresentation of their collaborative spirit, reducing their partnership to a basic rivalry. In doing so, the discussion highlights the importance of considering the contexts in which these biographies are written and the biases of their authors.
The Complexity of Masculinity and the Beatles
The complexities of masculinity within the Beatles' narrative are explored, indicating how each member managed their public personas and personal struggles. John Lennon's open discussions about vulnerability have been particularly resonant for fans, allowing for a connection that transcends typical celebrity worship. In contrast, Paul McCartney's more subdued portrayal often leads to misconceptions about his character and artistic contributions. This dynamic highlights the difficulties in separating personal identities from their artistic outputs and how public perceptions can distort actual experiences.
Fictional Representations in Biographical Narratives
The conversation addresses the use of fictional representations in biographical accounts of the Beatles, suggesting that these interpretations can provide insights beyond the rigid confines of factual storytelling. Fan-created narratives allow for explorations of emotional depth and internal struggles that are often absent from traditional biographies. This blending of reality and fiction serves to enhance the mythos surrounding the Beatles, adding layers that reflect cultural sentiments. As a result, it's posited that fiction can coexist with fact to create a more nuanced understanding of the band's legacy.
The Dynamics of Beatles Fan Culture
The dynamics of Beatles fan culture are highlighted, showcasing how communal experiences often enhance individual appreciation for the band. Conventions, online forums, and fan-driven projects create spaces for shared enthusiasm, allowing Beatles aficionados to connect over their love for the music. These interactions foster a stronger sense of identification and belonging among fans, reinforcing their commitment to the Beatles as cultural icons. Moreover, this communal aspect of fandom serves as a reminder of the impact that music can have in bringing people together around shared passions and experiences.
Cultural and Historical Context of the Beatles
The Beatles' story is rooted in specific cultural and historical contexts that shaped their music and public image. The discussion emphasizes how societal factors, including post-war Britain, played a pivotal role in their emergence and subsequent success. This contextual understanding helps illuminate the significance of their contributions to popular culture and the lasting influence they have exerted over the years. By looking at their story through this lens, fans and scholars alike can gain a deeper appreciation for the artistry of the Beatles and their intellectual legacy.
SUMMARY: Dr. Richard Mills joins Phoebe and Daphne for a chit-chat about all things fandom: slash fiction, Beatle novels, murder, conspiracies, tribute bands, horny editors, biopics, Superfan authors and anything else that pops up!
---
https://www.instagram.com/drrichardmills/
Dr Richard Mills is an Associate Professor in English Literature and Popular Culture at St Mary’s University, London. He has been programme director for the Film and Popular Culture, Cultural Studies and Irish Studies degrees. He has published extensively on popular music, Irish literature and culture, film, fashion and British television. Mills is the author of The Beatles and Fandom: Sex, Death and Progressive Nostalgia (Bloomsbury 2019). He is co-editor of Mad Dogs and Englishness (Bloomsbury 2017) and The Beatles and Humour (Bloomsbury 2023). He is author of the forthcoming The Beatles and Black Music: Post-colonial Theory, Musicology and Remix Culture (Bloomsbury 2025). Richard is a regular contributor to BBC4’s Last Word, Sky News, RTE, Portobello Radio and BBC Live. He is also on the editorial board of The Journal of Beatles Studies.
FURTHER READING
Understanding Fandom by Mark Duffett
Dancing in the Streets by Barbara Ehrenreich
The Historian and the Beatles by Erin Torkelson Weber
A Woman’s History of the Beatles by Christine Feldman Barrett
Beatleness: How the Beatles and Their Fans Remade the World By Candy Leonard
Shout, John Lennon: The Life and Paul McCartney: A Life by Philip Norman
Tune In by Mark Lewisohn
Revolution in the Head by Ian McDonald
Beatlebone by Kevin Barry
The Barracks by John McGahern
Memoir by John McGahern
Snodgrass and Other Illusions by Ian R. MacLeod
Across the Universe: Tales of Alternative Beatles by Michael A. Ventrellla and Randee Dawn
The Funkles!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EwEuWt_Ow_w
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
