Tyler Dalton McNabb and Erik Baldwin, "Classical Theism and Buddhism: Connecting Metaphysical and Ethical Systems" (Bloomsbury, 2023)
Dec 20, 2023
auto_awesome
Authors Tyler Dalton McNabb and Erik Baldwin discuss their book 'Classical Theism and Buddhism: Connecting Metaphysical and Ethical Systems'. They explore the compatibility between classical theism and Buddhism, address objections to their thesis, discuss the challenges of describing God, and delve into the synthesis of Buddhist and theistic ethics. They also explore the shift to Abrahamic traditions and the connection between Shinyata and God in a Zen context.
Buddhism and classical theism can coexist without contradiction by accepting the conceptual space for both metaphysical claims.
The book explores historical objections and philosophical arguments against the compatibility of classical theism and Buddhism.
A synthesis of classical theism and Buddhism is possible in ethics and soteriology, emphasizing common ethical principles and the potential for salvation in both traditions.
Deep dives
Buddhism and classical theism can be philosophically compatible
Buddhism and classical theism, despite their metaphysical differences, can be philosophically compatible.
The importance of defending the compatibility between Buddhism and classical theism
The authors argue that it is important to defend the claim that Buddhism and classical theism are compatible in order to further their previous work in comparative religious epistemology.
Exploring the metaphysical doctrines of classical theism and Buddhism
The book delves into the metaphysical doctrines of classical theism and Buddhism, exploring the ways in which they can be reconciled.
Analyzing objections to classical theism and Buddhism
The podcast episode explores objections to the compatibility between classical theism and Buddhism, including arguments from interaction, the resemblance objection, and the problem of evil.
Synthesizing classical theism and Buddhism in ethics and soteriology
The book argues for a synthesis between classical theism and Buddhism in ethics and soteriology, highlighting the common ethical principles and the possibility of salvation in both traditions.
In addition to denying the existence of a substantial, enduring self, Buddhists are usually understood to deny the existence of a God or gods. However, in Classical Theism and Buddhism: Connecting Metaphysical and Ethical Systems (Bloomsbury, 2022), Tyler Dalton McNabb and Erik Baldwin argue that there is conceptual space to affirm both basic Buddhist metaphysical claims and Classical Theism without contradiction. Their book argues that three fundamental commitments are generally agreed upon by Buddhists: all things are interdependent, impermanent, and empty of "own-being" (svabhāva). However, since Classical Theists like Aquinas deny that God—who is eternal, immutable, impassible, and metaphysically simple—is a thing among other things, accepting the existence of such a God poses no problem for a Buddhist. The book unpacks this thesis, also taking up historical Buddhist and contemporary philosophical objections to a divine being, arguing for a synthesis of Buddhist and theistic ethics and soteriology, and closing with a discussion of the problem of religious pluralism for Christians and Buddhists.