Bart Ehrman, New Testament scholar, joins Pete and Jared to discuss the historical reliability of the Gospels, highlighting the roles of oral tradition, authorial bias, and contradictions within the texts. They explore the criteria historians use to evaluate ancient written accounts and the impact of ancient historical consciousness on accuracy. They also discuss how the gospels were shaped by community beliefs and interpretations, as well as explore birth narratives, contradictions, and arguments against the mythicist belief.
The gospels are not intended to be historically accurate records, but rather proclamations of the good news, emphasizing the unique perspectives and messages each author wanted to convey about Jesus.
The reliance on oral tradition, coupled with the intent to emphasize certain aspects of Jesus' character or teachings, contributes to the variations and adaptations seen in the gospel accounts, dispelling the misconception that memorization ensures accuracy in oral cultures.
Deep dives
The Gospels and Historical Reliability
The podcast episode discusses the gospels and their historical reliability, featuring Bart Ehrman, a distinguished professor at the University of North Carolina. The gospels, namely Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, were written decades after the events they narrate and are not anonymous. Matthew and Luke are known to have used Mark as a source. The differences and contradictions between the gospels are crucial in understanding the unique perspectives and messages each author wanted to convey about Jesus. The episode emphasizes that the gospels are not intended to be historically accurate records, but rather proclamations of the good news.
Challenges of Oral Tradition
The podcast highlights the challenges of oral tradition in understanding the historical reliability of the gospels. It dispels the common misconception that memorization in oral cultures ensures accuracy. Most people in the Roman Empire were illiterate, and the authors of the gospels were unlikely to have been educated or taken written notes during Jesus' ministry. The reliance on oral tradition, coupled with the intent to emphasize certain aspects of Jesus' character or teachings, contributes to the variations and adaptations seen in the gospel accounts.
Interpreting Gospel Contradictions
The podcast explores the significance of contradictions within the gospels. Contradictions do not render the gospels historically unreliable, but rather reveal the unique perspectives and theological emphases of the authors. Comparing the birth narratives of Matthew and Luke, for example, illustrates their distinct storytelling styles and theological motifs. By appreciating the contradictions, one can better understand what each author sought to communicate about Jesus and his significance.
The Existence of Jesus
The podcast addresses the mythicist viewpoint, which denies the existence of Jesus. It affirms that, based on multiple historical sources, including the four gospels, the Apostle Paul, and other early Christian writings, there is overwhelming evidence to support the existence of Jesus. While questions remain about the specifics of Jesus' teachings and actions, his historical existence is widely accepted among serious historians.
We’re back for our eighth season of the podcast! In this episode of The Bible for Normal People, New Testament scholar Bart Ehrman joins Pete and Jared to discuss the historical reliability of the Gospels, highlighting the roles of oral tradition, authorial bias, and contradictions within the texts.
This episode is sponsored by Lumi. To learn more about microdosing THC, go to Microdose.com and use code NORMALPEOPLE to get free shipping and 30% off your first order.
**********
This episode is sponsored by Factor Meal Kits. Head to www.factormeals.com/normalpeople50 and use code normalpeople50 to get 50% off.
**********
This episode is sponsored by Fast Growing Trees. Right now, they have the best deals online, up to half off on select plants. Listeners get an additional 15% off when using the code NORMALPEOPLE at checkout. Head to FastGrowingTrees.com and use code NORMALPEOPLE at checkout. Offer valid for a limited time.