Ideas Rights vs Deservingness: How We Decide Who Belongs
Feb 12, 2025
In this thought-provoking discussion, Bart Bonikowski, an expert in sociology and politics, Alison Harrell, a political science professor, and Yasmin Aboulaban, a Canada Research Chair, dissect the complexities of deservingness in today's democracies. They explore how right-wing populism shifts the 'deservingness ladder,' influencing public opinion on who qualifies for social benefits. The conversation touches on topics like nationalism's evolving role in American politics, the impacts of surveillance on rights, and Canada's multiculturalism as a model for inclusive nationalism.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Language and Deservingness in Quebec
- In Quebec, language, particularly French, plays a significant role in deservingness assessments, especially regarding immigration.
- However, it doesn't override other factors like race, religion, or gender, but rather intersects with them.
EDI Policies in Alberta
- In Alberta, the United Conservative Party has challenged equity, diversity, and inclusion (EDI) policies in universities.
- They argue that funding should not be tied to EDI initiatives, potentially favoring certain groups.
Trumpism as Backlash
- The rise of Trumpism reflects a backlash against social and cultural change, including minority rights advancements.
- This backlash targets various groups and issues, aiming to revert to a previous status quo.