Explore the chaotic night at Astra Place Opera House during William Macready's Macbeth performance, the theatrical rivalry between Forrest and Macready, the intense competition fueled by media bias, and the repercussions of a regretful incident and high-profile divorce.
McCready's resilience amid chaos showcased his dedication to his craft.
Forrest's bold actions symbolized American defiance and pride amidst rivalry with McCready.
Deep dives
William Charles McCready: The Eminent Tragedian
William Charles McCready, a famed English actor, known for his exceptional portrayal of Shakespeare's Macbeth, embarked on a farewell tour in America. In the Astraplace Opera House, designed for the elite, the absurd audience reaction during his performance led to chaos. Despite the disruptions, McCready maintained composure, finishing the play amid flying seats and protest. The following day, supported by prominent citizens and heightened security, McCready staged a triumphant return to finish his performance, showcasing resilience and dedication to his craft.
Edwin Forrest: The American Rival
Edwin Forrest, a self-made American actor with a larger-than-life presence, rivaled McCready's classical acting style. The rivalry between Forrest and McCready intensified as Forrest challenged him across various American cities, sparking a fierce competition. Forrest's bold actions, like hissing during McCready's performance, exacerbated tensions, reflecting the clash between American working-class loyalty and English elite influence. Despite facing criticism, Forrest's theatrical zeal and impulsive actions elevated him as a symbol of American defiance and pride.
The Astor Place Riot: Theatrical Turmoil
The infamous Astor Place Riot marked a turning point in American theater history, triggered by the rivalry between Forrest and McCready. The riot, incited by nativist sentiments and class divisions, culminated in a tragic outburst of violence with casualties. The clash symbolized the societal upheaval and changing dynamics within theater audiences, influencing a shift towards a more controlled and decorous theatrical environment that emphasized civility and order.
Legacy and Controversy: McCready and Forrest
Following the Astor Place Riot, McCready retired from the theater, while Forrest faced a tarnished reputation due to a high-profile divorce and his perceived role in the riot aftermath. McCready's obituaries noted his longevity over Forrest, reflecting the lasting impact of their rivalry and the riotous events. Despite differing legacies, both actors left a lasting mark on American theatrical culture, embodying a turbulent era of passionate performances and dramatic confrontations.
As the famous English actor William Macready was preparing to go on stage in New York, over 300 police officers were placed in and around the theater. “But the head of the police said, ‘I don't know that that's going to be enough people.’”
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, members-only merch, and more. Learn more and sign up here.