68 | Peter Godfrey-Smith and middle class science

4 snips

Jan 14, 2025

Peter Godfrey-Smith, a renowned Professor of Philosophy of Science at the University of Sydney, dives into the complex interplay between creativity in science and philosophy. He discusses how scientists operate within structured paradigms while philosophers have more freedom. The conversation highlights the role of 'middle-class science'—independent labs that foster innovation—illustrated by breakthroughs like CRISPR. Peter also draws a captivating parallel between the transition of night to day and the evolution of scientific thought, reminiscent of Händel's aria.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Science vs. Philosophy

Science prioritizes the tractable and feasible, merging speculative ideas with empirical data.
This differs from philosophy, where creativity isn't limited by testability.

ANECDOTE

The Lamarck Incident

A young biologist mentioned "Lamarck" in a lab meeting, a forbidden word among geneticists.
The room fell silent, highlighting the constrained language within normal science paradigms.

INSIGHT

Value of Criticism

Negative criticism from reviewers can indicate that research is truly novel and impactful.
This contrasts with Kuhn's normal science where some questions are discouraged.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

Other Minds

The Octopus, the Sea, and the Deep Origins of Consciousness

Peter Godfrey-Smith

In this book, Peter Godfrey-Smith delves into the evolution of intelligence and consciousness, particularly in cephalopods such as octopuses and cuttlefish. He argues that these creatures represent an independent experiment in the evolution of large brains and complex behavior, distinct from the evolutionary paths of vertebrates. Godfrey-Smith draws on his own scuba-diving experiences and the latest scientific research to explore how these animals' unique neural structures, including decentralized brain-like systems in their arms, enable their remarkable intelligence and adaptability. The book also reflects on the broader implications for understanding human consciousness and the nature of subjective experience[1][2][5].

Living on Earth

Peter Godfrey-Smith

Theory and Reality

An Introduction to the Philosophy of Science

Peter Godfrey-Smith

Metazoa

Peter Godfrey-Smith

Peter Godfrey-Smith's "Metazoa" offers a sweeping overview of animal evolution, exploring the diversity of animal life and the major transitions in their history. The book examines the development of complex body plans, sensory systems, and behaviors across various animal groups. Godfrey-Smith discusses the evolutionary forces that have shaped animal life, including natural selection, adaptation, and environmental change. He emphasizes the interconnectedness of all animals and the importance of understanding their evolutionary relationships. The book provides a comprehensive and engaging account of the history and diversity of animal life on Earth.

The Structure of Scientific Revolutions

Thomas Kuhn

In 'The Structure of Scientific Revolutions', Thomas S. Kuhn argues that scientific progress does not occur through a gradual accumulation of facts, but rather through periodic revolutions that disrupt existing paradigms. Kuhn introduces the concept of 'normal science' and 'revolutionary science', where normal science involves puzzle-solving within an established paradigm, and revolutionary science involves a paradigm shift that fundamentally changes the way scientists view the world. He explains that these revolutions are driven by the accumulation of anomalies that cannot be explained by the current paradigm, leading to a crisis and eventually a new paradigm that offers a different perspective and new ways of conducting research[1][3][5].

Thinking, Fast and Slow

Daniel Kahneman

In this book, Daniel Kahneman takes readers on a tour of the mind, explaining how the two systems of thought shape our judgments and decisions. System 1 is fast, automatic, and emotional, while System 2 is slower, effortful, and logical. Kahneman discusses the impact of cognitive biases, the difficulties of predicting future happiness, and the effects of overconfidence on corporate strategies. He offers practical insights into how to guard against mental glitches and how to benefit from slow thinking in both personal and business life. The book also explores the distinction between the 'experiencing self' and the 'remembering self' and their roles in our perception of happiness.

Epigenetic Inheritance and Evolution

The Lamarckian Dimension

Marion J. Lamb

Eva Jablonka

Leviathan and the air-pump

Steven Shapin

Simon Schaffer