Family Court Q&A: Parental Alienation, Abuse Claims, and When to Stop Fighting
whatshot 12 snips
Nov 21, 2024
The hosts dive deep into the complexities of parental alienation and estrangement, clarifying the emotional struggles faced by families navigating high-conflict situations. They tackle listener questions about when to give up the fight in court against manipulative ex-partners and highlight the concept of 'legal abuse.' Discussions also examine how ADHD can affect parenting dynamics and advocate for more individualized assessments in family court. Insights into the prevalence of false allegations illuminate the challenges faced by protective parents.
31:44
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Refuse And Resist As The Umbrella Problem
'Refuse and resist' describes the umbrella behavior when a child resists contact after separation or divorce.
Parental alienation occurs when one parent's bad-mouthing and interference cause the child to absorb blame and resist the other parent.
insights INSIGHT
Estrangement From Parental Harm
Realistic estrangement happens when a child fears a parent due to that parent's violence or abuse.
Estrangement stems from the parent's harmful behavior, not from the other parent's influence.
insights INSIGHT
Three Hypotheses For High-Conflict Cases
Avoid presumptions: consider three theories — the allegation is true, it's false, or both parents behave badly.
Decide each case on evidence rather than ideological commitments to one explanation.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Tackling Listener Questions on High Conflict Personalities in Family Law
In this episode of It's All Your Fault, Bill Eddy and Megan Hunter address questions from two listeners about high conflict personalities in family law. They dive into the complexities of parental alienation, domestic violence allegations, and when to stop fighting in court.
Listener Question 1: Understanding Parental Alienation and Estrangement
The first listener asks about the confusion surrounding parental alienation. Bill defines key terms: "refuse and resist," parental alienation, and realistic estrangement. He explains the differences between alienation caused by one parent's behavior and estrangement resulting from a parent's own actions, such as domestic violence or child abuse.
Listener Question 2: When to Stop Fighting in Court
The second listener, from Australia, asks when to give up the fight with a high conflict ex-partner who continues to violate court orders. Bill and Megan address the issue of "legal abuse" and the limitations of the court system in handling these situations effectively.
Questions We Answer in This Episode:
What is the difference between parental alienation and realistic estrangement?
How common are false allegations of abuse in family court?
When should you stop fighting in court with a high conflict ex-partner?
Key Takeaways:
Consider all possibilities in each case without presumptions.
Parental alienation and domestic violence both exist and require careful assessment.
Fighting in court for more than two years may be counterproductive.
Obtain transcripts of court hearings to address false statements or bad decisions.
This episode provides valuable insights for anyone navigating high conflict personalities in family law. Bill and Megan offer a balanced perspective, emphasizing the need for an open mind and case-by-case analysis.
All of our books can be found in our online store or anywhere books are sold, including as e-books.
You can also find these show notes at our site as well.
Note: We are not diagnosing anyone in our discussions, merely discussing general patterns of behavior. Nor are we providing legal of therapeutic advice. Please seek the assistance of your local professionals to seek help.
(00:00) - Welcome to It's All Your Fault
(00:36) - Listener Questions
(01:18) - Question 1: Parental Alienation
(21:54) - Question 2: When to Give In
(30:37) - Reminders & Coming Next Week: More Listener Questions
It’s All Your Fault: High Conflict People 
