Journalist and market research analyst Ross Benes dives into his book, which explores the cultural landscape of 1999. He draws intriguing parallels between beanie babies and the rise of cryptocurrency. The discussion reveals how WWE's political triumph marked a shift in media perception and the age of deregulation. They dissect moral panics, the evolution of consumer culture, and the blurred lines between entertainment and reality, ultimately reflecting on how lowbrow culture continues to shape modern society.
The 1990s' low culture, exemplified by reality TV, has sculpted contemporary political dynamics towards sensationalism over substance.
Beanie Babies represent a harbinger of today's speculative investing behaviors, illustrating humanity's recurring obsession with collectible fads.
The concept of kayfabe blurs reality and performance in politics and media, reshaping public perception of authenticity in narratives.
Deep dives
The Impact of Low Culture in Politics
The influence of low culture, particularly from the 1990s, is evident in today's political landscape, as contemporary politics mirrors the sensationalism and drama of reality TV and talk shows from that era. The discussion suggests that leadership styles frequently resemble the outrageous behavior displayed in shows like Jerry Springer, indicating a cultural shift towards valuing entertainment over substantive governance. This trend is exemplified by the rise of figures who leverage charisma and controversy for political gain, akin to reality stars. Therefore, the current political sphere reflects not just a changing political environment but an overarching low culture that has taken hold in various aspects of society.
Cultural Collectibles and Modern Analogues
The phenomenon of collectible crazes like Beanie Babies in the 1990s serves as a precursor to modern trends in speculative investments such as cryptocurrencies and NFTs. These collectibles drew immense public interest and investment similar to the irrational enthusiasm surrounding current digital assets, highlighting human tendencies toward irrational financial behavior linked to perceived value. Just as Beanie Babies were marketed as valuable items before their inevitable decline, today's market offers similar hype yet without sustainable backing. This cyclical nature of cultural collectibles illustrates the persistent appetite for fads and trends that ignite mass enthusiasm, regardless of their long-term viability.
Kayfabe and Reality in Entertainment
The concept of kayfabe, borrowed from professional wrestling, signifies the presentation of staged events as real, and it has permeated various aspects of modern entertainment and politics. This phenomenon reflects a blurring of lines between authentic experiences and fabricated spectacles, as seen in social media and reality shows that expect audiences to accept dramatized narratives as truth. The merging of kayfabe-like strategies into political discourse, particularly through the lens of figures who derive their personas from entertainment, further complicates the public's understanding of reality versus performance. As kayfabe influences political engagement and sensationalizes public narratives, it showcases how entertainment values have infiltrated everyday life.
The Role of Technology in Cultural Evolution
Technological advancements in the late 1990s significantly reshaped the distribution and consumption of media, paving the way for low culture to dominate mainstream entertainment. Innovations such as cable television and the internet allowed for a decentralized media landscape where niche interests could flourish, removing traditional gatekeepers. This shift facilitated the rapid spread of lowbrow entertainment, ultimately leading to a cultural environment where sensationalism often outweighs substance. The resulting landscape underscores the relationship between technological progress and shifts in cultural consumption, illustrating how new platforms enable low culture to thrive.
The Evolution of Celebrity and Fame
The current landscape of celebrity culture reflects a shift towards figures who achieve fame through reality television, mirroring paradigms established in the 1990s. Influencers today often engage audiences in ways reminiscent of reality TV stars, driving engagement through manufactured drama and curated personas. This phenomenon reveals a transformation in how celebrity is perceived, as individuals gain notoriety for their online presence rather than traditional accomplishments. Notably, this trend emphasizes the allure of being famous for simply being famous, challenging previous notions of merit and artistic contribution in the entertainment industry.
Jonah Goldberg is joined by author and research analyst Ross Benes to discuss his new book, 1999: The Year Low Culture Conquered America and Kickstarted Our Bizarre Times. Jonah and Ross discuss beanie babies as a precursor to crypto, the political triumph of the WWE, and the age of media deregulation. Plus: the phenomenology of moral panics and the bourgeois-ification of transgressive culture.
The Remnant is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including Jonah’s G-File newsletter, regular livestreams, and other members-only content—click here.