Douglas Watt, author of "The Price of Scotland," dives into Scotland's ambitious yet disastrous attempt to colonize Panama in the late 17th century. He discusses the dreams of wealth and trade that drove the ill-fated Darien scheme, where 1,200 settlers faced harsh realities, tropical diseases, and ultimately, death. Watt reveals how this national catastrophe not only impacted those who ventured to Darien but also reshaped Scotland's economy and fueled the urgency for political union with England.
Scotland's Darien scheme aimed to create a trading hub but faced dire consequences due to underestimating colonial challenges and competition.
The disastrous failure sparked political unrest in Scotland, leading to calls for a union with England as a bailout strategy.
Deep dives
The Ambitious Venture into Darien
In the late 17th century, Scotland's ambition to establish a colony in Darien, modern-day Panama, was driven by the desire to emulate successful trading companies like the English East India Company and the Dutch East India Company. The venture, led by William Patterson, aimed to create a trading hub that could control trade routes between the Caribbean and the East Indies. However, the Scots underestimated the challenges of colonization, including competition from powerful empires such as Spain, which had longstanding claims to the region. The naive belief that the Spanish Empire was in decline was a miscalculation that would soon prove disastrous.
The Catastrophic Expeditions
The first expedition to Darien faced severe hardships, including treacherous weather and infectious diseases, resulting in significant loss of life even before reaching the colony. The settlers initially experienced excitement upon arrival, but the harsh realities of the tropical environment soon took their toll. High mortality rates forced the first group to abandon the settlement, and a subsequent expedition suffered a similar fate, marked by escalating health crises and conflicts with the Spanish. By the end of these ill-fated attempts, a majority of the original 2,500 Scottish settlers had perished, leaving only a small number to return home.
Political Fallout and Financial Implications
The failure of the Darien scheme triggered an outpouring of anger and blame directed at both the directors of the Company of Scotland and the English government. The immense financial loss, coupled with the perceived damage to national pride, ignited political unrest in Scotland that reverberated through the parliamentary sessions of 1700-1701. Many Scots believed they were betrayed by the English, who not only refused assistance but made efforts to hinder trade with the colony. This discontent eventually paved the way for calls for a union with England, as the prospect of a bailout for the investors became politically appealing in the wake of the disaster.
The Union as a Financial Transaction
In the aftermath of Darien, the English government proposed a bailout for the shareholders of the Company of Scotland as a means to incentivize the union between Scotland and England. This financial arrangement, dubbed the 'Equivalent,' was crucial in securing parliamentary support for the union, compensating those who lost significant investments in the disastrous scheme. While the economic backlash from the failed venture was real, some historians argue that its lasting impact has often been overstated, as signs of recovery emerged in the Scottish economy shortly after. Ultimately, the Darien scheme not only represented a tragic chapter in Scotland’s history but also served as a catalyst for political change, yielding a complex interplay of economics and national identity.
In the late 17th century, Scotland tried to establish a colony in Panama - and it all went horribly wrong.
In July 1698, a fleet of five ships departed from the Firth of Forth with some 1,200 people onboard. They were bound for the Isthmus of Panama, a paradise in Central America, and their goal was to establish Scotland's first colony - New Caledonia. It was a bold, desperate gamble, intended to save Scotland from financial ruin. But only one year later, most of the settlers were dead, and the colony had been abandoned.
To tell us about the Darien scheme and how it all went wrong, we're joined by Douglas Watt, author of 'The Price of Scotland'. He explains what happened when the settlers arrived in Panama and the consequences for Scotland as a whole.
Produced by James Hickmann and edited by Dougal Patmore.
Enjoy unlimited access to award-winning original documentaries that are released weekly and AD-FREE podcasts. Sign up HERE for 50% off for 3 months using code ‘DANSNOW’.
We'd love to hear from you - what do you want to hear an episode on? You can email the podcast at ds.hh@historyhit.com.