Is Too Much Local Democracy to Blame for the Housing Crisis?
Sep 16, 2024
auto_awesome
Jerusalem Demsas, a staff writer at the Atlantic and author of "On the Housing Crisis: Land, Development, Democracy," delves into the complexities of America’s housing crisis. She argues that local governance, with its tangled zoning boards and committees, is a significant yet overlooked culprit. While many point fingers at greedy developers or corrupt politicians, she reveals how these hyper-local decisions play a critical role. Demsas emphasizes the implications for marginalized communities and discusses the necessity for reform to tackle the housing shortage.
Local government policies and decentralized housing authority significantly hinder new home construction, exacerbating the housing supply shortage.
The affordability crisis disproportionately impacts marginalized groups, revealing critical socio-economic divides that affect access to basic needs.
Gentrification is driven primarily by exclusionary zoning practices, necessitating reforms to promote equitable development and affordable housing.
Deep dives
Understanding the Housing Affordability Crisis
The housing affordability crisis is increasingly impacting individuals and families across various demographics, leading to significant personal hardships. Rising rents and home prices consume a substantial portion of people's incomes, resulting in reduced access to essential needs like healthcare and education. This economic strain disproportionately affects younger individuals, those on fixed incomes, and marginalized groups, highlighting the critical socio-economic divide. Such circumstances reveal that without access to affordable housing, many struggle to maintain a decent quality of life, pushing the crisis to urgent national prominence.
The Role of Local Government in Housing Supply
Local government policies have been identified as key factors contributing to the ongoing housing supply shortage. Decentralized housing authority has allowed localities to impose strict regulations that often hinder the construction of new homes, resulting in a staggering deficit of around four million housing units. This reduction in supply, coupled with growing demand, exacerbates the affordability crisis and has extended from urban centers to suburban regions where housing was once more accessible. The complexity of the approval processes and public opposition contributes to a stagnant housing market that necessitates urgent reform.
Skepticism Surrounding Housing Supply Solutions
While there is a common belief that increasing the housing supply could help alleviate affordability issues, skepticism persists regarding its sufficiency to resolve the crisis. Observers often mistakenly attribute rising home prices to the volume of construction rather than the mismatch between job growth and new housing availability. This skepticism is compounded by personal experiences and perceptions of changing neighborhood dynamics, leading individuals to doubt economic theories surrounding supply and demand. Understanding this disconnect is essential for engaging communities in meaningful discussions about effective solutions.
The Complexity of Gentrification and Housing Dynamics
Gentrification adds another layer of complexity to the housing affordability debate, as new market-rate units are often blamed for displacing lower-income residents. However, studies indicate that demographic shifts within cities result primarily from exclusionary zoning practices that limit development in affluent areas. The availability of new homes in wealthier neighborhoods is critical to reducing displacement pressures in lower-income areas, as unsatisfied demand leads to rapid price increases when new people move in. Addressing development barriers and promoting new construction across diverse neighborhoods can mitigate these gentrification impacts.
Strategies for Addressing the Housing Crisis
Effective strategies must be developed to address the housing crisis, focusing on building a sufficient supply of housing while considering the diverse needs of communities. Potential solutions include reforming local zoning laws to allow more flexible development standards and ensuring the inclusion of affordable housing options within new projects. Additionally, state governments can play a crucial role in facilitating development by removing unnecessary regulatory burdens and incentivizing public-private partnerships. A holistic approach, which assesses both supply and demand dynamics, is essential for creating sustainable solutions that accommodate all income levels.
Most Americans are now acutely aware that we have a housing crisis, but Atlantic writer Jerusalem Demsas says that we have much less clarity about what’s causing it. “All too often,” she writes, “explanations center around identifying a villain: greedy developers, or private equity companies, or racist neighbors, or gentrifiers, or corrupt politicians.” All which may be true, she says, but they fail to identify the root cause, that housing decisions are made at the hyper local level, in a tangle of zoning boards, historical preservation committees and sparsely attended meetings, “where no one is watching and no one is accountable.” We talk to Demsas about her new collection of essays, “On the Housing Crisis: Land, Development, Democracy” and why she thinks local governments are to blame for the housing shortage.
Guests:
Jerusalem Demsas, staff writer, Atlantic Magazine; author, On the Housing Crisis: Land, Development, Democracy
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode