The Prestige TV Podcast ‘Nobody Wants This’ Season 2 Review: Too Much of a Good Thing
32 snips
Oct 30, 2025 The hosts dive into the complexities of relationships in Season 2, exploring how Noah and Joanne's dynamics shift. They question the overuse of pop culture references and the show’s handling of religious themes, particularly the lack of deeper faith engagement. Character growth takes center stage, with Esther’s arc emerging as a highlight. They critique Joanne's limited development, discuss pacing issues, and speculate on future storylines, while praising the sharp humor and standout performances that keep the narrative lively.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Chemistry Over Clear Tone
- Season one’s chemistry made the show a comfort-watch despite tonal uncertainty in production.
- Rob Mahoney argues the central Noah–Joanne relationship carried the show more than explicit religious exploration.
Supporting Cast Steals Focus
- Season two broadens the cast and spotlighted supporting players more than the leads.
- Both hosts praise new performances (Jackie Tohn, Justine Lupe) that improve the show’s appeal.
Culture Over Theology
- The show flirts with religion but largely avoids serious theological discussion.
- Rob notes it treats Judaism more as cultural practice than lived faith.