

The Prestige TV Podcast
The Ringer
The Prestige TV Podcast is your home for instant reactions, deep dives, creator interviews, and Hall of Fame retrospectives on the best television around. Join a rotating cast of Ringer personalities including Bill Simmons, Joanna Robinson, Rob Mahoney, Mallory Rubin, Van Lathan, and more as they break down the shows you're binging and the ones you're waiting to drop every week. Subscribe to The Prestige TV Podcast, check back weekly for our breakdowns, and most importantly, keep watching.
Episodes
Mentioned books

19 snips
Nov 21, 2025 • 56min
‘Pluribus’ Episode 4: Carol’s Truth Serum
Jo and Rob dive into the complex dynamics of individuality versus collectivism in the latest plot twists. They explore Carol's disdain for the hive mind through her bold experiments, including a risky truth serum test with Larry. The discussion also touches on Carol's past with drugs and how her artistic integrity clashes with societal pressures. Engaging listener emails and fascinating comparisons to iconic shows like The Matrix add depth to their analysis. Prepare for a thought-provoking look at character motivations and emotional truths!

Nov 19, 2025 • 1h 3min
Netflix’s ‘The Beast in Me' Review
Dive into Netflix’s gripping miniseries with a spoiler-filled discussion. Discover Matthew Rhys’s captivating villainy and the emotional weight Claire Danes brings to her role. The hosts fiercely debate the ambiguous evidence surrounding the murders. They explore themes of ambition and betrayal, while analyzing the FBI subplot's effectiveness. Join them as they compare dark mirrors in storytelling, and highlight pivotal moments that challenge characters' morals. A thrilling conversation packed with insights awaits!

Nov 18, 2025 • 40min
'Death by Lightning': Netflix's Hit Garfield Assassination Show, With Mike Makowsky | Prestige TV
Screenwriter and producer Mike Makowsky, known for his work on Netflix's limited series, dives into the riveting adaptation of Candace Millard's book about Garfield's assassination. He discusses the intriguing choice to keep the series at four episodes and how he modernized historical dialogue to engage contemporary audiences. The conversation touches on the actors' deep portrayals and the complexity of Garfield’s character, as well as the fascinating decision to feature Guiteau's brain in a jar as a thematic element. This blend of history and drama captivates throughout!

32 snips
Nov 14, 2025 • 1h 18min
‘Pluribus’ Episode 3: Negative Nancy at the Ice Hotel
Jo and Rob dive into the emotional layers of ‘Pluribus’, exploring themes of individuality versus the hive mind. They hilariously dissect listener emails while debating whether shared consciousness stifles creativity. The complexities of Carol’s character unfold, revealing her grief and the comforting influence of 'Golden Girls'. There's also a quirky discussion about the visual symbolism of uniforms and the show's humorous moments, like the DHL guy. Plus, they ponder the moral implications of a hive mind, including its limits on consent.

69 snips
Nov 7, 2025 • 1h 15min
Vince Gilligan’s ‘Pluribus’: Episodes 1-2 Breakdown
Jo and Rob dive into the intriguing world of 'Pluribus,' highlighting Apple TV's premiere crash and its unexpected publicity. They explore the show's hefty budget and unconventional casting choices, emphasizing Gilligan's signature style of dark humor and procedural storytelling. The conversation turns philosophical as they debate the nature of threats—alien versus viral—and the implications of AI on community. They also analyze character motivations, striking visuals, and the ethical pitches woven throughout the narrative, all while offering playful banter and listener engagement.

32 snips
Oct 30, 2025 • 54min
‘Nobody Wants This’ Season 2 Review: Too Much of a Good Thing
The hosts dive into the complexities of relationships in Season 2, exploring how Noah and Joanne's dynamics shift. They question the overuse of pop culture references and the show’s handling of religious themes, particularly the lack of deeper faith engagement. Character growth takes center stage, with Esther’s arc emerging as a highlight. They critique Joanne's limited development, discuss pacing issues, and speculate on future storylines, while praising the sharp humor and standout performances that keep the narrative lively.

Oct 29, 2025 • 1h 2min
‘Slow Horses’ Season 5 Finale Recap
Jo and Rob delve into the tensions and triumphs of the Season 5 finale of ‘Slow Horses.’ They dissect the meaning behind the title 'Scars' and explore Jackson Lamb's intriguing backstory. A humorous discussion unfolds about Lamb’s memorable sausage roll moment, and Catherine's spy prowess shines through as she thwarts threats. The duo also debates the effectiveness of the season's plot and anticipates new characters for the next season. Expect insights on moral ambiguities and the future of beloved characters!

Oct 22, 2025 • 53min
'Slow Horses' Season 5 Episodes 3-5 Breakdown With Alan Sepinwall
Alan Sepinwall, a veteran TV critic and author working on books about Rod Serling and The Wire, joins Joanna to analyze key moments from Slow Horses. They dive into Jackson Lamb's complex monologue, debate River Cartwright's bumbling character shift, and explore the implications of Louisa's absence. Alan praises Tom Brooke's unsettling performance as Ko and critiques the show's choice of Libyan antagonists. They also discuss Apple's branding challenges and upcoming projects, including the anticipated Vince Gilligan series.

43 snips
Oct 20, 2025 • 57min
‘Task’ Finale: Chasing Greatness
The hosts dive into the finale of 'Task,' assessing its place among HBO's greatest series. They spotlight Mark Ruffalo's powerful performance, particularly his restrained courtroom scene, and share their favorite moments, like the emotional kitchen scene. Speculation flows about potential season two directions, including new character arcs and crossovers. They break down action scenes, analyze character developments, and discuss nitpicks about realism. The debate on whether revealing the mole earlier would enhance the story adds an intriguing twist.

11 snips
Oct 13, 2025 • 1h 23min
‘Task’ Episode 6 With Creator Brad Ingelsby
In this lively discussion, creator Brad Ingelsby shares insights about casting Tom Pelphrey, whose portrayal of Robbie adds depth with his flaws. He delves into Grasso’s complex backstory and the emotional weight of key scenes, emphasizing the show's moral ambiguities. Ingelsby also hints at a potential second season, exploring new storylines while bringing back the beloved cast. The creative choices, including a nod to 'Heat,' show how character-driven narratives shape intense drama.


