The podcast dives into the Taliban's strict enforcement of morality laws, especially targeting women's rights, amidst a deepening humanitarian crisis. It discusses the historical rise of the Taliban and their centralized control over Afghanistan, leading to severe public service impacts. The show highlights the harsh realities under their rule, including rising unemployment and the international community's diplomatic dilemmas as they navigate relations with unrecognized governance. The precarious situation of women, in particular, shows the complex interplay of rights, economics, and global response.
The Taliban's centralized governance structure, led by Hebatollah Ahunzada, severely restricts civil liberties and undermines public agency in Afghanistan.
Economic hardships disproportionately affect women and girls, exacerbating inequalities while humanitarian crises persist amid the regime's international isolation.
Deep dives
Taliban Governance Structure
The Taliban's governance structure is characterized by a strict hierarchy led by their supreme leader, Hebatollah Ahunzada, who centralizes authority and control over policy decisions in Afghanistan. Despite retaining some elements of the previous government’s structure, the Taliban has reinforced its command by appointing religious scholars to ensure that government functions adhere to their interpretation of Sharia law. This centralization of power has resulted in a lack of agency for both civil servants and the general populace, as dissenters face severe repercussions from an extensive surveillance and intelligence network. Consequently, civil liberties have significantly eroded, with public safety being heavily skewed in favor of the regime's power dynamics rather than the welfare of everyday Afghans, especially women and minorities who are subjected to strict societal constraints.
Economic Crisis and Its Impact on Women
The crippling economic conditions in Afghanistan have disproportionately impacted women and girls, exacerbating inequalities and leading to alarming health disparities. Reports indicate that serious malnutrition is more common among girls due to cultural norms favoring boys in desperate households, and women have faced a staggering 25% drop in employment opportunities since the Taliban's resurgence. Western sanctions intended to pressurize the Taliban have ironically resulted in plummeting healthcare standards, leading to shortages of essential medical supplies and increased humanitarian needs. While the Taliban has attempted to stabilize some aspects of the economy, including reducing imports from western countries, the resultant job scarcity and increased gender restrictions ultimately hinder the potential for women's empowerment and broader economic recovery in the country.
International Relations and Recognition Challenges
Despite not being officially recognized by any country, the Taliban has engaged in diplomatic interactions with several states, utilizing their strategic advantages to forge economic partnerships, particularly with China and Russia. Javid Ahmad highlights the complexities facing Western nations as they navigate their relationship with a regime that is viewed as a coalition of varied factions, each with differing ideologies and agendas. The ongoing humanitarian crisis has compelled the United States to remain a key donor of aid, aiding basic stability while also posing a challenge due to the Taliban's restrictive governance. The uncertain future of Afghanistan hinges on the Taliban's ability to reconcile with diverse Afghan interests, as continued isolation poses the risk of severe humanitarian crises and increased regional instability.
Just over three years ago the Taliban seized Kabul and stormed to power in Afghanistan. They soon declared a new government which is still not recognised by any other country.
The Taliban claim they have made improvements to the country. War is over and, they say, there is more peace and security than before they came to power.
But millions of people are struggling to survive in the country, there is a restrictive rule of law that is imposed by a very hierarchical government structure and half the population need aid.
This week on The Inquiry we’re asking ‘How are the Taliban governing Afghanistan?’
Presenter: Emily Wither
Producers: Louise Clarke and Matt Toulson
Editor: Tara McDermott
Technical Producers: Nicky Edwards and Cameron Ward
Contributors:
Dr Weeda Mehran, co-director for Advanced Internationalist studies at Exeter University
Graeme Smith, senior analyst for the International Crisis Group
Dr Orzala Nemet, research associate at ODI Overseas Development Institute
Javid Ahmad, non-resident scholar at the Middle East Institute in Washington DC
(Photo by WAKIL KOHSAR/AFP via Getty Images)
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
