051 - Does Being a Good Person Make You a Worse Competitor?
Jun 27, 2024
auto_awesome
Discussing the correlation between negative character traits and sports performance, including the balance between confidence and ego. Exploring how athletes can maintain confidence while focusing on team goals and personal growth. Addressing the necessity of delusion and confidence in competitive fields, and the impact of contrasting personalities on performance. Examining how parenthood can affect athletes' identities and performance, highlighting the struggle of managing different roles.
Certain character traits, termed performance enhancing vices by Sabrina Little, can influence athletic performance. These traits, like pride, envy, and selfishness, may help athletes push beyond limits, but they can clash with character development. While pride can induce delusional confidence boosting performance, excessive selfishness or dishonesty, seen in doping cases, have negative ethical implications.
Balancing Ego and Performance: The Impact of Pride
Pride, a double-edged trait in sports, can lead to overestimating abilities or valuing oneself above others. While self-assurance drives performance, excessive pride may hinder cooperation and growth. Research suggests elite performers maintain a touch of optimism without delusion, emphasizing clear perspectives over exaggerated self-importance.
Reputation Protection in Athletics: A Double-Edged Sword
In the realm of athletics, reputation protection can veer into harmful territory, impacting performance negatively for most individuals. While elite athletes like Michael Jordan excel under this pressure, most succumb to the threat, affecting their competitive edge. Cultivating a balance between confidence and humility is pivotal for sustained success.
Thriving Outside of Competition: Establishing Personal Boundaries
Maintaining a life beyond sport enhances athletic performance, reflecting in improved results and mental health. Wresting with one's identity amidst intense competition demands conscious effort to delineate roles and priorities. Setting boundaries, focusing on varied interests, and engaging in non-sporting pursuits foster holistic well-being and sustainable athletic success.
Steve, Brad, and Clay discuss a question posed by the writer and runner Sabrina Little in a recent article (link below) from Aeon titled "Performance-Enhancing Vices:" How do the personality traits that make for better competitors impact moral character? Is it possible that things like envy, selfishness, and pride—traits we'd likely label as "vices"—make us more competitive? Does good character hurt our performance? Using contemporary examples and drawing on their own experiences coaching, competing, and working with elite athletes, the guys explore the relationship between athletic performance and moral character. When does selfishness help and when does it hurt? Do you have to singularly obsessed to be great? How should we think about balancing life with ambitious goals?
"Performance-Enhancing Vices" by Sabrina Little (Aeon):