Intimacy, Breakups, and Dating in the Real World: A Conversation with Dr. Justin Garcia

Dating and relationships have never been simple — but in today's world of apps, algorithms, and endless options, it's easy to feel overwhelmed and disconnected. In this episode, I speak with Dr. Justin Garcia, Executive Director of the Kinsey Institute, evolutionary biologist, sex researcher, and author of the upcoming book The Intimate Animal. We talk about what our biology can (and can't) tell us about love and desire, how technology is reshaping intimacy, and why breakups can hit so hard.

We also get personal — sharing stories about grief, recovery, non-monogamy, and navigating love in the real world. Dr. Garcia brings a refreshingly nuanced perspective, blending science, lived experience, and a deep respect for the complexities of modern relationships.

Topics Covered

• The biological basis of pair bonding and why love is a survival strategy

• How dating apps are changing the way we connect — and the pitfalls of infinite choice

• Non-monogamy, open relationships, and what science really says about them

• Breakups, heartbreak, and why they feel like addiction withdrawal

• Infidelity: what motivates it, and why it's often about secrecy more than sex

• Practical dating advice backed by years of research

• The neuroscience of attraction, and how foreplay, communication, and intention keep passion alive

• How personal experience shaped Dr. Garcia's latest work — including his own recent marriage and fatherhood

Guest Bio

Dr. Justin Garcia is an evolutionary biologist, sex researcher, and Executive Director of the Kinsey Institute at Indiana University. He's also the Chief Scientific Advisor for Match Group, guiding large-scale studies on modern relationships like the annual Singles in America survey. His research has been featured in outlets like The New York Times, TIME, and CNN, and his new book The Intimate Animal: The Science of Sex, Fidelity, and Why We Live and Die for Love will be released on January 27, 2026.

Learn more: Kinsey Institute Bio – https://kinseyinstitute.org/about/staff/executive-director-justin-garcia.html Pre-order The Intimate Animal – https://www.hachettebookgroup.com/titles/justin-r-garcia-phd/the-intimate-animal/9780316594035/

Resources Mentioned

• Singles in America study – https://www.singlesinamerica.com/

• Kinsey Institute – https://www.kinseyinstitute.org/

• Dr. Garcia's social media: Search "Dr. Justin Garcia" on major platforms or follow updates via the Kinsey Institute

Key Takeaways

• Love and sex are biologically distinct but deeply intertwined. We're wired for long-term bonding, but novelty and desire often create tension within those bonds.

• Breakups are more than emotional — they're neurochemical. Love activates the brain's reward systems, and heartbreak can mimic drug withdrawal.

• Modern dating can feel overwhelming because our brains haven't evolved to handle endless digital choice. Intention and curiosity matter more than perfection.

• Non-monogamous relationships aren't inherently less loving or stable. They often demand high levels of communication and negotiation.

• Infidelity is less about desire and more about secrecy. Even in non-monogamous relationships, broken trust hurts.

• There's no perfect formula for love. Each connection is unique, and understanding yourself can help you show up better in relationships.

Connect with Me

Have a question, topic suggestion, or want to be a guest? Email: duffthepsych@gmail.com Website: https://duffthepsych.com Contact form: https://duffthepsych.com/contact

Please rate and subscribe on your favorite podcast platform — it helps more people find the show!