Mormon Stories Podcast Joseph Smith's First Year of Polygamy in Nauvoo - John Turner Pt. 27 | Ep. 2102
Jan 9, 2026
Historian John G. Turner, author of *Joseph Smith: The Rise and Fall of an American Prophet*, joins the discussion to examine Joseph Smith's early polygamous practices. He reveals the origins of polygamy in Nauvoo, highlighting its secretive nature and the dynamics of power and belief involved. Turner delves into the challenges Smith faced, including legal threats and opposition, while weighing the complex motives behind his controversial actions. The conversation unearths ethical questions about consent and authority, painting a vivid picture of this turbulent chapter in Mormon history.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Theology Meets Opportunity
- Joseph had thought about polygamy episodically for years and embraced it as he reimagined exaltation in Nauvoo.
- Turner links theological conviction plus newfound confidence in Nauvoo to Joseph's decisive move into polygamy.
Secrecy Around Revelation
- Joseph kept many close confidants in the dark, including Emma and key counselors, while initiating plural marriage.
- Turner emphasizes that secrecy was central as Joseph began teaching polygamy to select families.
The Beeman Sealing Under An Elm
- Joseph approached the Beeman family and asked to be sealed to Louisa with Joseph Bates Noble as intermediary.
- Noble later claimed the sealing was consummated and that Louisa disguised herself during the outdoor ceremony.
