AI-powered
podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
The ADL has a history of conflating anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism, arguing that criticism of Israel equates to singling out Jews and anti-Semitism. By categorizing groups like Students for Justice in Palestine and Jewish Voice for Peace as extremist, the ADL blurs the lines between political expression and hate speech.
The ADL's recent focus on supporting the Trump-negotiated Abraham Accords aligns it closely with pro-Israel policies. The organization presents the accords as fostering tolerance and fighting anti-Semitism in the Middle East, despite evidence to the contrary, highlighting its political stance over human rights concerns.
The ADL's claim to represent all American Jewish people is questioned in light of its alignment with specific political agendas. There is a need for alternative organizations that focus on combating anti-Semitism without using it as a tool to shield Israel from criticism.
There are discussions on the legitimacy of organizations tracking hate crimes, considering the framing of individual hate incidents versus systemic discrimination. Alternative approaches that address structural hate and discrimination may offer a more comprehensive understanding of combating anti-Semitism and promoting human rights.
There is a need to address anti-Semitism without conflating it with anti-Zionism. While institutionalized anti-Semitism is not prevalent in the US, there are concerns about anti-Semitism flaring up, especially from white supremacist and right-wing groups. Organizations educating about anti-Semitism are crucial to prevent misrepresentation in movements for justice like Palestine.
Groups working on anti-Semitism education often struggle with limited funding and lack of credibility in mainstream media. Local initiatives like J.French Jews for Racial and Economic Justice in New York and Parsdao provide anti-Semitism curriculum from a justice-based lens. The emergence of a larger, more centralized anti-Semitism education group could be beneficial due to the credibility crisis faced by current organizations such as the ADL.
The concept of inverting the victim and victimizer narrative in certain discourses is explored, highlighting how power dynamics are manipulated to portray anti-Israel sentiments as antisemitic. The reliance on solipsistic criteria to define victimhood often leads to a distortion of reality, deflecting attention from actual atrocities, like the ongoing genocide in Gaza.
The manipulation of language and history is utilized to trigger emotional responses and divert attention from real issues. Words like 'intifada' and 'from the river to the sea' are misrepresented and exploited to paint legitimate protests or resistance as threatening. This tactic, combined with mythologizing and victimization narratives, serves to maintain complacency and perpetuate harmful ideologies.
The influence of certain media outlets in shaping narratives around protests and geopolitical conflicts plays a significant role in public perception. The generational gap in media consumption, with younger audiences turning to alternative sources for information, highlights the evolving landscape of media credibility. This shift challenges traditional power structures in media and politics.
Tactics of deflection and victimhood are wielded by those in power to evade accountability and portray legitimate protest as intimidation. The intentional flattening of political complexities and the inversion of power dynamics serve to distract from urgent issues like genocide and systemic injustices. By amplifying minor threats while ignoring grave atrocities, these tactics perpetuate a cycle of misinformation and manipulation.
Alternative media sources play a crucial role in providing diverse perspectives and challenging mainstream narratives. Critical engagement with information is essential to combat misinformation and bias. By supporting independent journalism and seeking out diverse voices, individuals can cultivate a more informed and nuanced understanding of complex issues such as genocide, oppression, and resistance.
"Ex-officer Amber Guyger testifies in wrong-apartment murder trial: 'I was scared to death,'" a " story reported in 2019. "Starbucks Files Complaints with Labor Board, Accuses Union Organizers of Bullying and Harassment," reported Food & Wine Magazine in April 2022. "Labour MPs fear for safety as pro-Palestine protesters target offices," The Guardianwarned in November 2023. Within the last decade, we’ve seen the rise of a phenomenon we’ll refer to as “elite crybullying," in which people in power engage in political manipulation in order to portray themselves as victims. Routinely, we hear that armed American police fear for their safety around unarmed civilians, lawmakers feel for the their safety after there's a sit in protest and corporate executives are being unfairly intimated by union organizers.
It's a sleazy, manipulative tactic that not only flattens, but flips, power dynamics. By claiming to have been bullied or traumatized by those who oppose them, wealthy and influential figures suddenly transform themselves from victimizers into victims. Meanwhile, by this same perverse logic, they characterize their actual victims–be they organizing workers and peace activists, who merely seek to stand up for themselves, or people killed by military and police violence – as victimizers.
On this episode, we explore the rise of ruling-class crybullyism, how elites increasingly traffic in the language of anti-bullying and therapy-speak to indemnify themselves from criticism, examine how cynical distortions of power relations recast the upholders of colonialism, labor abuses, and police violence as the oppressed, and the people who dare to object as the oppressors, all in an effort to silence dissent from the justifiably angry masses.
Our guests are Mari Cohen and Saree Makdisi.
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode