Jane Marie, host of The Dream, discusses the downsides of coaching and positive thinking. Dr. Sherman James and Dr. Arline Geronimus explore the negative impacts of striving. The podcast delves into the American Dream, multi-level marketing, and health inequity.
Striving for success can have negative impacts on the health and happiness of marginalized communities, highlighting the need for systemic improvements.
The belief in individual effort and a positive attitude for success absolves systemic issues and perpetuates socioeconomic inequalities, calling for a shift in understanding and advocating for policy changes.
Deep dives
The Legend of John Henry and Its Meaning
The podcast explores the legend of John Henry, a symbol of the American dream and the belief that hard work leads to success. It delves into the different interpretations of the legend, highlighting its significance for African Americans and the struggle against adversity. The episode introduces Dr. Sherman James and his research on high blood pressure and the health consequences of striving for excellence. It reveals a correlation between high effort coping and hypertension, even among successful individuals. The takeaway is that striving for success can come at a cost, particularly for marginalized communities.
The Strain of Weathering and Chronic Stress
The podcast features Dr. Arlene Geronimus, who presents the concept of 'weathering' in relation to health inequity. She explains how chronic stress and coping mechanisms impact marginalized communities, leading to health problems that emerge earlier in life. The episode highlights the psychological toll of constant striving, juggling multiple jobs, and facing structural obstacles. It challenges the notion that positivity and resilience alone can overcome systemic barriers, emphasizing the deeper social and economic factors at play.
The Illusion of the American Dream
The podcast critiques the prevalent mindset in American culture that success is solely achieved through individual effort and a positive attitude. It discusses how this belief absolves systemic issues and perpetuates socioeconomic inequalities. The episode explores how motivational speakers and self-improvement movements often ignore the physiological costs associated with striving for success. It calls for a shift in understanding the American dream and advocating for policies that alleviate the burden on individuals striving for upward mobility.
The Need for Change and Education
The podcast concludes by highlighting the importance of acknowledging and addressing the negative consequences of relentless striving. It emphasizes the need for public awareness, education, and policy changes to create a more equitable society. The episode aims to challenge the prevailing narrative of individualism and encourage systemic improvements that provide equal opportunities for all.
On The Dream, host Jane Marie gets to know the life coaches and gurus who claim they know the secret to living our best lives. Is it all in our mindset? Or our privilege? Or are we all under a spell?
Tim Harford is joined by Jane Marie to talk about who coaching works least well for. Turns out it’s the exact people who could benefit most from it, according to the industry. Dr. Sherman James and Dr. Arline Geronimus discuss the downsides of positive thinking, bootstrapping, and mindset culture. For some people, striving has negative impacts on health and happiness.