This podcast explores the intersection between the legal system and neuroscience. It discusses topics such as the insanity defense, the Twinkie Defense, and using premenstrual syndrome as a criminal defense. The podcast also delves into real-life cases, the challenges of determining insanity, and the evolution of the insanity defense. It concludes by emphasizing the complexity of society and available resources at eagelman.com/podcast.
The podcast explores the history and complexities of the insanity defense in the legal system, discussing different approaches and tests used to determine criminal liability and the impact of mental illness on the ability to appreciate right from wrong.
The episode examines the role of volition in assessing criminal liability and the insanity defense, presenting cases where individuals had impaired volition, exhibiting impulse control issues despite their ability to understand right from wrong.
Deep dives
The Insanity Defense
The podcast explores the history and complexities of the insanity defense in the legal system. It delves into different approaches and tests used to determine criminal liability and the impact of mental illness on the ability to appreciate right from wrong. The episode discusses famous cases, such as Andrea Yates, and highlights the challenges in accurately assessing mental state in criminal trials. It also addresses public perceptions and misconceptions about the insanity defense, and the ongoing debate surrounding its effectiveness and fairness.
The McNaughton Rules
The McNaughton Rules, established in the 19th century, initially defined the insanity defense requiring clear proof of a disease of the mind that impaired the ability to understand right from wrong. The episode outlines the limitations of this narrow cognitive approach and the criticism it faced. It also explores the evolution of the insanity defense with the introduction of the Durham rule, the Bronner rule, and the Insanity Defense Reform Act, each aiming to broaden or modify the criteria for determining insanity.
The Role of Volition
The episode examines the role of volition in assessing criminal liability and the insanity defense. It presents cases where individuals had impaired volition, exhibiting impulse control issues despite their ability to understand right from wrong. The challenges of determining volition and its impact on culpability are discussed, including the difficulty of proving that an act was the product of a mental defect and the role of psychiatric expert testimony.
Challenges and Public Perception
The podcast raises concerns about the public resistance and misconceptions surrounding the insanity defense. It highlights the rarity of its use and the stringent criteria required for a successful plea. The episode also discusses the consequences of the insanity defense, such as long-term institutionalization and debates over punishment versus treatment. The complexities of balancing legal and psychiatric perspectives and the need for ongoing evaluation and refinement of the insanity defense are highlighted.
What does the insanity defense mean in a court of law? And is there such a thing as temporary insanity? Is the twinkie defense a real thing? Can someone use premenstrual syndrome as a defense? And what does the legal wrestling around insanity tell us about the differences between brains: yours and other people’s, or even yours one day and yours the next day? How does law comport with science, and how are they sometimes like two people with quite different ways of looking at the world? Join to find out what happened to Andrea Yates, how the legal system deals with mental illness, and so much more.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode