Understanding Insanity and the Limitations of the McNaughton Rules

This chapter explores the history and concerns surrounding the McNaughton Rules, which determine whether someone knows the difference between right and wrong and understands the consequences of their actions. It raises questions about the absolute knowledge of psychiatrists and lawyers, as well as the limitations of the rules in cases where an individual is only temporarily confused or lacks clarity during a small window of time. The chapter also delves into various real-life cases and explores different defense strategies used in these cases.