In this engaging discussion, Rudy Giuliani, former mayor of New York City, shares insights on the fierce cable news rivalry of the 1990s, particularly between Fox News and CNN, spearheaded by media mogul Rupert Murdoch. They delve into Murdoch's strategy to launch Fox News amid corporate battles and the challenges posed by Time Warner’s dominance. The conversation highlights how major scandals motivated viewership, the intense competition for ratings, and the shifting media landscape, revealing the behind-the-scenes tensions and alliances that shaped modern news.
Fox News' launch in 1996 marked a pivotal shift towards opinion-driven programming, positioning itself as a conservative alternative in a competitive landscape.
The intense rivalry between Fox News and CNN exemplified the influence of major news events, which significantly shaped viewer engagement and network credibility.
Deep dives
The Birth of Fox News
In January 1996, Roger Ailes and Rupert Murdoch announced the creation of the Fox News Channel, marking a significant shift in the landscape of 24-hour news. Murdoch highlighted the growing demand for news that resonates with viewers, emphasizing the need for a network that explains how current events impact people's lives. Despite a modest budget of $80 million, which was substantially less than CNN's, Ailes expressed confidence that the network’s unique approach would help it thrive. The announcement set the stage for Fox News to challenge established networks by positioning itself as a conservative alternative in the news industry.
Struggles for Distribution
As Fox News prepared for its launch, it encountered formidable obstacles regarding distribution, particularly in New York, where Time Warner held significant power. Despite securing agreements with various cable providers, Time Warner refused to carry Fox News, opting instead for MSNBC, which highlighted the competitive tension between the two emerging networks. Murdoch's attempts to negotiate with John Malone, the head of the largest cable provider, illustrated the intricate dynamics of media distribution and the risks involved in launching a new news channel. The roadblocks raised concerns about Fox News' ability to reach critical mass, essential for its success.
Political Maneuvering and Legal Battles
In response to Time Warner's decision, Roger Ailes orchestrated a campaign to pressure the company, leveraging political connections, including support from New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani. Ailes presented Fox News as a champion of free speech and a necessary competitor against what he framed as Time Warner's monopolistic practices. The escalating tensions resulted in a $1.8 billion antitrust lawsuit against Time Warner and efforts to influence regulatory bodies reviewing the cable company’s franchise agreements. These strategies underscored the lengths to which Fox News would go to secure distribution and carve out its niche in the competitive news landscape.
Shift in Viewer Engagement
As Fox News battled for its place in the market, it began capitalizing on significant news events, particularly the presidency of Bill Clinton, to draw in viewers. The network's opinion-driven programming differentiated it from its competitors, leading to increased ratings during the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, allowing Fox to pull ahead of MSNBC. In contrast, CNN faced challenges that impacted its reputation, such as the fallout from the controversial Operation Tailwind story, which diminished its credibility. This shift in viewer engagement patterns highlighted the fluid dynamics of ratings in an industry driven by major news events and public perception.
It's 1996 and Fox News is getting ready to launch, but when CNN owner Time Warner tries to block it, Rupert Murdoch seeks help from New York mayor Rudy Giuliani. Then, a scandal rocks the White House and proves to be a ratings magnet for both channels. And CNN takes a major hit when its reporting comes into question.
Listen to Business Wars on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. Experience all episodes ad-free and be the first to binge the newest season. Unlock exclusive early access by joining Wondery+ in the Wondery App or on Apple Podcasts. Start your free trial today by visiting wondery.com/links/business-wars/ now.