Susan Neiman discusses her book 'Left Is Not Woke' and the clash between emotion and logic in defining left-leaning values. They explore identity, intersectionality, being Jewish, and challenges faced by the left like proto-fascism and the climate crisis.
'Woke' is now a divisive term used to attack anti-discrimination efforts by the right wing.
The left emphasizes economic equality and sees social rights as equal to political rights.
Deep dives
Wokeness as a Slur
The term 'woke' has become a slur used by the right to attack those working against racism, sexism, and homophobia. The concept of 'wokeness' has turned into a derogatory term, leading some people to discourage using it in book titles or promoting it in any way that it could be seen as contributing to right-wing agendas.
Defining Wokeness and Confusion
The concept of 'wokeness' has caused confusion and controversy, with people claiming that it has ruined the left. However, many of these criticisms seem to come from the right-wing and lack a clear understanding of what being left means in this context. Author Susan Neiman emphasizes that her book is an attempt to define what it means to be left, rather than defining 'wokeness' itself.
Regressive Assumptions
The concept of 'wokeness' is often based on regressive assumptions about identity, power, and progress. It reduces individual identities to ethnicity and sex, undermining the belief in deep connections and obligations to people beyond one's own tribe. Furthermore, it rejects the notions of distinguishing power from justice and the possibility of progress. These assumptions contradict the core values of the left, which include a commitment to universalism, justice, and progress.
Left versus Liberal
Neiman differentiates between the left and the liberal perspectives. While social rights are considered genuine human rights for the left, liberals tend to view them as secondary to political rights. The left believes in the importance of economic equality and acknowledges the equal weight of social and political rights. Neiman expresses a willingness to make common cause with liberals in the face of growing fascism around the world.