New Books in Popular Culture

James Brown's War on Disco

Nov 11, 2025
Alice Echols, a prominent historian and author of "Hot Stuff: Disco and the Remaking of American Culture," delves into the intricate role of disco in 1970s society. She discusses how disco transcended its musical roots to reflect racial and sexual politics, challenging the notion of it being "politically empty." Echols contrasts the lush sounds of disco with James Brown's tight funk, highlighting disco's ties to Black artistic agency. From Barry White's redefinition of Black masculinity to the complexities of interracial solidarity, this conversation reveals disco's profound cultural significance.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

James Brown's Public Rejection Of Disco

  • James Brown announced a cultural battle with his 1976 exhortation "Get up off of that thing" to push back against disco.
  • The song marked his attempt to reclaim dance floors and radio from the rising disco sound.
INSIGHT

Dance Floors As Political Space

  • Echols links disco's dance practices to gay liberation because same-sex dancing had been prohibited and thus embodied political meaning.
  • She treats dance-floor behaviors as inseparable from broader LGBTQ politics of the era.
INSIGHT

Disco's Internal Cultural Debate

  • Disco was created by and for Black audiences but faced criticism within Black music circles as "politically empty."
  • Echols shows producers like Nile Rodgers used irony and layered meaning, complicating the charge of vacuity.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app