The McShay Show The 2025 NFL Redraft: A New QB1, Hunter Hindsight, and the Pats Pass on Campbell | The McShay Show
Dec 25, 2025
Steve Muench, a football analyst and contributor, joins Todd McShay to dive into the intriguing world of the 2025 NFL redraft. They debate Tennessee's choice of QB Tyler Shough as the top pick and discuss edge rusher Abdul Carter’s potential for the Jaguars. The duo analyzes a tackle decision for the Patriots, weighing Will Campbell against Kelvin Banks Jr. They also highlight strategic selections by the Jets and Dolphins while exploring the best fits and surprising picks, providing a fascinating look at team needs and player value.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Tyler Shough As New QB1
- Todd McShay argues Tyler Shough has performed as the season's best quarterback and merits a No.1 redraft pick.
- McShay cites measurables, mobility, and recent high-output games as proof of his case.
Long Talk With Shough At Manning Camp
- Todd McShay recounts spending nearly an hour talking one-on-one with Tyler Shough at Manning Passing Academy.
- He says that conversation reinforced his belief in Shough's competitiveness and resilience.
Abdul Carter's Upside Outweighs Stats
- Steve Muench believes Abdul Carter remains the most talented edge rusher in the class despite modest sack totals.
- He values disruptive upside and thinks Carter can still become an elite pass rusher.