Joel Beall, senior writer at Golf Digest and author of *Playing Dirty*, joins to discuss the ongoing stalemate between the PGA Tour and LIV Golf, shedding light on failed negotiations and the impact of Saudi influence on professional golf. The conversation also highlights the dominance of No. 1 seeds in March Madness and Alex Ovechkin's pursuit of Wayne Gretzky’s goal record. The panel dives into the striking contrast in player dynamics and explores the Yankees' recent home run success linked to their innovative torpedo bats.
The PGA Tour's negotiations with LIV Golf reveal a deep-seated conflict over integrating new formats while preserving traditional structures and integrity.
LIV Golf's heavy financial backing from Saudi Arabia has successfully increased diplomatic relations, despite ongoing questions about its sustainability and viewer appeal.
Ethical dilemmas surrounding sportswashing and the normalization of partnerships with controversial entities raise concerns about the future of professional athletics, particularly golf.
Deep dives
PGA Tour and LIV Golf Negotiations
The ongoing negotiations between the PGA Tour and LIV Golf highlight the complexities of integrating team events into traditional golf formats. Challenges have arisen since the proposed deal from June 2023, as many in the golf community are now doubtful about its fruition. The PGA Tour's reluctance to adopt LIV’s team format stems from concerns over maintaining the integrity and structure of the existing tour. As discussions stall, both sides exhibit a growing sense of detachment, with players indicating they no longer see the necessity for a deal, despite previous optimism.
Impact of LIV Golf on Professional Golf Landscape
Since its inception, LIV Golf has fundamentally altered the dynamics of professional golf, particularly by attracting top players with lucrative contracts. While it has yet to establish itself as a self-sustaining league in terms of viewership, the substantial financial backing from Saudi Arabia has achieved its primary goal of increasing diplomatic relations. Conversely, the PGA Tour perceives Liv’s success as diminishing in terms of player departures, with only a single prominent player, Jon Rahm, defecting recently. This situation has led to a strategic reassessment within the PGA Tour regarding LIV's contribution to the future of golf.
Challenges in Player Reunification
The potential reunification of LIV and PGA Tour players poses significant ethical challenges, particularly for those who sued the PGA Tour after leaving. Many PGA Tour players are now wary of reintegrating those who sought to undermine the tour’s operations, leading to conflicts regarding punishment and forgiveness. Tour officials generally favor reconciliation, yet there remains a vocal faction advocating for consequences against former LIV players. The situation reflects a broader sentiment of fatigue within the golf community, stemming from the ongoing conflict and its ethical implications.
Cultural and Financial Implications of Sportswashing
The relationship between LIV Golf and controversial geopolitical figures, including Donald Trump and the Saudi government, has raised awareness of sportswashing in the sports community. The normalization of partnerships with entities known for human rights violations poses ethical dilemmas, particularly as fans become desensitized to these issues. Despite earlier scrutiny, debates about LIV Golf's impact on human rights are diminishing, with public focus shifting towards the league’s business and entertainment aspects. This normalization indicates a dangerous precedent for other sports, potentially opening the door for increased Saudi investment across various athletic disciplines.
Historic Perspectives on Golf and Future Prospects
The evolving landscape of professional golf is being shaped significantly by current negotiations, historical rivalries, and the changing values within the sport. The integration of LIV into PGA structures could pave the way for Saudi investment in other major sports, prompting a reevaluation of ethical standards in professional athletics. As fans and players grapple with these developments, the legacy of golf is at a crossroads, with the potential for long-lasting impacts on how the game is played and perceived. Future outcomes will likely set precedents for how sports interactions with geopolitical forces evolve in the years to come.
Hosts Alex Kirshner, Lindsay Gibbs, and Ben Lindbergh welcome Joel Beall, senior Golf Digest writer and author of Playing Dirty, for a deep dive into Saudi Arabia’s continued sportwashing through investments in professional golf. The panel also discusses number one seeds steamrolling their way into the men’s Final Four. Alex Ovechkin inches closer to surpassing Wayne Gretzky's NHL goal record. Finally, Ben has an afterball on the Bronx Bombers and their new, lethal torpedo bats.
On the bonus episode available exclusively for Slate Plus members, the panel talks about foul-grifting and faking injuries in the NBA.
LIV Golf (2:43): Why the PGA Tour/Saudi Arabia negotiations really failed.
March Madness (29:45): For the second time ever, the men’s Final Four is all No. 1 seeds
Ovechkin (45:18): The Capitals captain is five goals shy of surpassing Gretzky
(Note: time codes are only accurate for Slate Plus members, who listen ad-free.)
Want more Hang Up and Listen? Subscribe to Slate Plus to immediately unlock weekly bonus episodes. Plus, you’ll access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe now on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page, or visit slate.com/hangupplus to get access wherever you listen.
