Coffee House Shots: what's the point of public inquiries?
Jan 11, 2025
auto_awesome
Isabel Hardman, Assistant Editor at The Spectator, sheds light on the complexities of public inquiries, questioning their effectiveness in delivering justice. Raja Miah, an anti-grooming gang campaigner, passionately argues for a nationwide inquiry, citing the failures of past investigations. They explore whether these inquiries genuinely hold power accountable or merely distract from needed legislative changes. The discussion also touches on restoring public trust in institutions and the emotional toll on victims when inquiries fall short.
Campaigners argue that a national inquiry into grooming gangs is essential for truth and justice, despite recent parliamentary setbacks.
Historical examples indicate that public inquiries often fail to prompt significant political action, leaving victims without meaningful accountability or support.
Deep dives
The Need for a Public Inquiry
Campaigners emphasize the critical importance of a public inquiry into the grooming gang scandal, viewing it as a quest for truth and justice. Despite disappointment with a recent parliamentary vote against a nationwide inquiry, campaigners consider it a victory that the issue remains a topic of national discourse. The classification of the perpetrators as 'Pakistani heritage' by the Home Secretary marks a significant shift in conversation, countering accusations of far-right rhetoric against those advocating for the inquiry. Local inquiries, reliant on the goodwill of witnesses, are deemed insufficient to uncover the systemic failures involved; only a national inquiry can aspire to hold those responsible accountable.
Challenges of Public Inquiries
Public inquiries are often seen as necessary but fraught with delays and inadequate follow-through on findings, leading to a lack of accountability. Historical examples, such as the Chilcot inquiry and the mid-staff's inquiry, reveal that while initial investigations may spark intense public interest, meaningful political action often subsides once the inquiries are concluded. Consequently, victims may find themselves retraumatized without the assurance that insights will lead to systemic change. The political culture tends to focus on individual actions while neglecting broader policy implications, perpetuating a cycle of neglect towards victims and their needs.
The Dynamics of Political Accountability
Raja expresses waning faith in governmental institutions and underscores the need for a public inquiry to restore trust in democracy and political representation. He points out that a commitment to addressing these issues through structured inquiries, rather than riots or protests, is crucial for community healing. The conversation surrounding potentially new political parties asserting their own inquiries adds complexity to the current situation, as previous experiences indicate that simple promises without understanding the process can lead to further disappointment. This highlights the necessity for a more effective and responsive inquiry system capable of compelling political action based on inquiry recommendations.
This week, MPs voted against a new national inquiry into grooming gangs. The vote followed weeks of pressure on Labour after Elon Musk brought grooming gangs back into the spotlight, after safeguarding minister Jess Phillips rejected a new national inquiry.
If we did have a national inquiry, what would it achieve? We’ve had many in recent years; Iraq, Grenfell Covid, the Post Office. Do they achieve meaningful justice for victims, or are they a drawn-out way to avoid knotty legislative change? Does parliament have the mechanisms to enact the recommendations – have politicians ever done this in the past, and is there an appetite to do so in the future?
Deputy broadcast editor Natasha Feroze discusses with Spectator assistant editor Isabel Hardman, and Raja Miah, anti-grooming gang campaigner and Oldham commentator.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode