Commotion with Elamin Abdelmahmoud

Should you read it before you watch it?

Nov 18, 2025
C.T. Jones, a culture and pop-culture writer, champions reading books first for deeper emotional engagement. Jo Saul, co-owner of Type Books, explores how adaptations can boost book sales and discusses the balance of reading versus watching. Film critic Bilge Eibiri argues for watching films first to enjoy them without distractions. The trio dives into the adaptation trend, audience fatigue with repetitive IP, and the thrill of discovery in bookstores. Their spirited debate is filled with insights on how storytelling unfolds in both books and films.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ADVICE

Read To Know The World First

  • Read the source book to enter the story world and form your own emotional response before the film reshapes it.
  • Reading first lets you judge the adaptation on its own terms rather than reacting only to changes.
INSIGHT

Watch First To Avoid Comparison

  • Watching the movie first prevents you from constantly comparing film choices to your imagined version and improves enjoyment of both works.
  • Bilge Eibiri found reading-after-watching preserved her ability to enjoy each medium independently.
ANECDOTE

Hamnet At TIFF Felt Communal

  • Jo Saul described seeing Hamnet at TIFF as a communal, emotionally intense experience led by director Chloé Zhao's pre-screen breathing exercise.
  • She was glad she had read Maggie O'Farrell's novel first because it prepared her for the film's deep sadness.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app