Discussing American politics post-Republican convention with expert Gary Gerstle. Analyzing Trump's strategy, potential vice presidential pick J.D. Vance, speculation on Biden replacement, and impact of Trump on Bidenomics.
Trump's acceptance speech at the Republican Convention featured rally-style elements and a shift towards economic populism.
Opinions on Trump's speech varied with effective moments on surviving the assassination attempt but transitioned into rambling sections.
Potential scenarios post-assassination attempt for Democratic strategy include rallying around Kamala Harris and conducting a town hall primary contest.
Deep dives
Trump's Acceptance Speech
Trump's acceptance speech at the Republican Convention was described as lengthy and resembling a rally speech. The speech, lasting an hour and a half, featured elements of interaction with the crowd and a call-and-response aspect. Descriptions of his rallies are contrasted with the convention speech, noting that the rally-style elements may not have translated effectively on TV.
Impact of Trump's Speech
Opinions on Trump's acceptance speech varied, with a consensus that the first 20-25 minutes were effective, focusing on surviving the assassination attempt. However, the speech transitioned into rambling and boastful sections as critics found it overwhelming. Some observers noted a shift in impression from subdued emotion at the start to a more authentic portrayal of Trump later in the speech.
Strategic Shifts in the Republican Party
The Republican Party's evolution towards economic populism is highlighted, emphasizing managed trade over free markets and a focus on manufacturing. Trump's foreign policy-heavy speech at the convention, condemning Biden and praising figures like Viktor Orbán, underscores a shift towards isolationism and strongman leadership.
J.D. Vance and Post-Assassination Speculations
J.D. Vance's selection as a potential VP nominee after the Republican Convention is discussed. Speculation on Vance's background, political journey, and connections to Silicon Valley is outlined, suggesting his alignment with economic populism despite personal ties to tech elites. Vance's speech focusing on the Rust Belt signals a potential strategy shift in the party.
Potential Scenarios and Division in the Democratic Party
Contemplation on potential scenarios post-assassination attempt regarding Democratic strategy and candidate selection is examined. The likelihood of rallying around Kamala Harris or conducting a town hall primary contest to determine the nominee is considered to prevent party divisions. The importance of a unified and decisive strategy in navigating the candidate transition is emphasized for future electoral success.
This week we check back in with Gary Gerstle to discuss what’s been happening in American politics after a tumultuous week. What does it say about Trump’s electoral strategy that he picked J.D. Vance as his running mate? How would the Republican party have coped if the assassin’s bullet hadn’t missed? Who might replace Biden at the top of the Democratic ticket and how? Plus, what fate lies in store for Bidenomics if Trump plasters his name all over it?
Our free fortnightly newsletter is out now, including reflections on Biden’s and America’s looming choices – just sign up here https://linktr.ee/ppfideas
And sign up to PPF+ to get all our bonus episodes along with ad-free listening: available now for PPF+ subscribers, Robert Saunders on his favourite political novel, George Eliot’s Felix Holt
