Karen Bethea-Shields, lawyer for Joan Little's self-defense case, discusses the challenges faced by Black women in the justice system. Topics include societal bias, legal strategies, and the emotional trial climax leading to Joan's acquittal.
Advocating for marginalized communities in criminal defense was Karen Bethea Shields' driving force, leading to her successful defense of Joanne Little against biased attitudes and societal challenges.
Joanne Little's trial highlighted the importance of empathy, truth, and fair representation, culminating in her historic acquittal as the first woman in the US to be found not guilty of murder for resisting sexual assault.
Deep dives
Karen's Determination to Become a Criminal Defense Lawyer
Karen Bethea Shields knew from the outset of law school that she wanted to focus on criminal defense, particularly helping marginalized communities like poor people and African Americans facing incarceration. Starting her career with civil rights work under lawyer Jerry Paul, she quickly transitioned into representing Joanne Little, a young African-American woman accused of killing a jailer who attempted to assault her. Karen's unwavering dedication to advocating for marginalized individuals shines through her decision to pursue criminal defense.
Joanne Little's Self-Defense Case
Joanne Little, a 20-year-old woman, found herself in a dire situation when she killed a jailer who tried to rape her in self-defense. After escaping from custody, Karen Bethea Shields took on her case, advocating for self-defense as the primary argument. Despite facing societal and legal challenges due to biased attitudes towards black women and sexual assault victims, Joanne's trial centered on the narrative of defending oneself against sexual violence.
Trial and Acquittal of Joanne Little
The trial of Joanne Little led to intense courtroom moments, with Karen Pathea Shields strategically emphasizing empathy and putting the jury in Joanne's shoes during her closing argument. Despite a challenging legal battle and racial biases, the jury acquitted Joanne Little within an hour and a half of deliberation. The trial highlighted the significance of truth, justice, and fair representation in the criminal justice system.
Legacy of Joanne Little's Case and Karen's Legal Career
Joanne Little's case marked a pivotal moment in legal history as the first woman in the US acquitted of murder for resisting sexual assault with deadly force. Karen's impactful defense work not only secured Joanne's freedom but also propelled her own legal career, ultimately cementing her path to becoming the first female and black female judge in Durham County. The case's enduring impact underscores the need for fair and empathetic legal representation for marginalized individuals in the criminal justice system.
When Karen Bethea-Shields was in college, she heard a judge say, “No way in the world a Black woman can get raped.” A few years later, in 1975, she helped successfully defend Joan Little—a Black woman—who became the first woman in the U.S. to be found not guilty of murder using the defense that she used deadly force to resist sexual assault.
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, members-only merch, and more. Learn more and sign up here.