Guest Mark Williams, a visiting professor at Loughborough University and a leading expert in skill acquisition, tackles sports coaching myths. He challenges the simplicity sought by coaches, emphasizing the art of coaching over scientific dogma. They discuss the constraints-led approach and the importance of adjusting practice environments for young footballers. Mark also sheds light on the misconceptions of skill transfer and explores how visual skills enhance player performance, urging coaches to create engaging, long-term learning experiences.
The constraints-led approach enhances skills by mimicking competition demands, but its effectiveness varies based on the coach's and players' experience levels.
Coaches should focus on long-term learning rather than short-term performance metrics, balancing directive methods with player autonomy for skill acquisition.
Deep dives
The Role of Constraints in Coaching
The constraints-based approach is a method where coaches manipulate practice conditions to enhance skill development. This method has shown that specificity in training—mimicking competition demands—leads to better transfer of skills. However, the effectiveness of this approach might vary depending on the experience level of the coach and the players, raising concerns about novice coaches adequately changing constraints. An experienced coach might intuitively know how to adjust practice variables for skilled players, while inexperienced coaches may struggle to make informed decisions about what to manipulate.
Understanding Learning and Performance
Coaches often confuse immediate performance with long-term learning. While prescriptive coaching can lead to improved performance in practice sessions, it may not foster sustainable learning. To genuinely assess learning retention, patterns should be observed over time, rather than relying solely on short-term performance metrics. Therefore, adaptability in coaching styles—balancing between directive approaches and providing room for player autonomy—can better support long-term skill acquisition and behavioral change.
The Myths of Skill Transfer Across Sports
There is a prevalent belief that engaging in multiple sports can enhance proficiency in a primary sport; however, scientific evidence supporting this is limited. Transfers of skills are more likely to occur between similar sports, but the specific elements that contribute to transfer remain largely unknown. Coaches should consider players' interests and preferences instead of forcing diversions into unfamiliar sports, as this could lead to disengagement. Ultimately, encouraging participation in various sports should be balanced with respecting a child's passion for their chosen sport.
Visual Function and Perception in Sports
Elite athletes are often thought to possess superior visual abilities, but research suggests that the differences lie more in perceptual-cognitive skills than in biological visual functions. Effective scanning and awareness during competition are crucial, as skilled players excel at interpreting visual cues and predicting gameplay dynamics. Training should focus not only on the mechanics of visual scanning but also on developing knowledge structures that enhance decision-making in real-time. By creating realistic training scenarios, players can develop the cognitive skills needed for higher-level competitive performance.
In this episode, Dan Cottrell sits down with renowned sports scientist and learning expert Mark Williams to explore some of the most controversial and misunderstood myths in sports coaching.
Mark is a visiting professor at the School of Sport, Exercise and Health Sciences at Loughborough University. A world-leading expert in skill acquisition, Mark has authored 20 books and nearly 300 research papers and advised top sports organisations like FIFA, UEFA, and the EPL.
Drawing from Mark's thought-provoking LinkedIn series, they delve into key topics like the "constraints-led approach," the limitations of "skill transfer," and the role of "visual superiority" in player development.
Should coaches be worried about myths in coaching, or do they offer a pathway to deeper insight? Mark addresses this head-on, revealing how scientific nuance often clashes with the simplicity coaches crave. Discover why coaching is more art than science, how to strike the right balance between "hands-on" and "hands-off" approaches, and why learning and performance aren't always as connected as we think.
This episode will challenge your assumptions, sharpen your coaching instincts, and offer practical guidance on how to create more effective learning environments — whether you’re working with novice players or elite athletes.
To find out more about this podcast and many others, go to Rugby Coach Weekly
Also, tap into the library of 4,000 pages of activities, advice, tactics and tips to help you become the best rugby coach you can be!
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode