Anne Applebaum, a renowned journalist and historian at The Atlantic, discusses the rise of modern autocracies and the complexities they present to opposition movements. She delves into the financial tactics of kleptocracies and the chilling effects of surveillance technologies. The conversation touches on Trump's views on dictators, the normalization of autocratic values in U.S. politics, and the challenges posed by regimes like Putin's in Ukraine. Applebaum also reflects on why contemporary leaders often lack grand ideologies, favoring cynicism instead.
Autocratic regimes in the 21st century are increasingly collaborating and sharing oppressive tactics, complicating opposition efforts against them.
Advanced technology and sophisticated propaganda enable dictatorships to distort the truth, making it harder for citizens to resist autocratic narratives.
Deep dives
The Rise of Global Autocracies
The emergence of autocratic regimes in the 21st century is characterized by their increasing collaboration and shared tactics. Dictatorial states are now forming networks, sharing technologies for surveillance and propaganda, and mimicking each other's oppressive strategies. This cooperation complicates efforts by opposition movements to effect change, as they face not just local regimes but a collective of empowered dictatorships that often maintain unique ideologies. Historical strategies for opposition, such as mobilizing civil society and mass movements, are becoming progressively ineffective in light of these developments.
Technology's Role in Modern Propaganda
Advanced technology has transformed traditional propaganda, enabling regimes to disseminate messages through a multitude of sources, thus complicating the public's perception of truth. For example, the Russian state media employs various channels to deliver a controlled narrative, circumventing the simplicity of government-controlled communications of the past. Countries like China have developed extensive surveillance frameworks, effectively monitoring dissent and leveraging digital platforms for information control. This sophisticated manipulation poses challenges for citizens seeking to resist autocratic narratives and emphasizes the need for vigilance in the digital age.
Financial Networks Empowering Autocrats
Contemporary kleptocracies thrive within a complex international financial system that allows leaders to hide their wealth and conduct shady transactions unimpeded. Modern dictators often utilize entities such as shell companies and anonymous trusts to obscure their financial dealings, thus evading accountability. This has led to an alarming trend where a significant portion of global wealth is concealed in tax havens, a reality that is often enabled by the very democratic systems that oppose autocracy. As the stakes increase, it becomes essential to address these financial mechanisms that support dictatorial regimes.
The Challenge to Democracy from Autocratic Narratives
The influence of autocratic regimes extends beyond borders, as they actively shape narratives in democracies to align local sentiments with their anti-democratic ideologies. This shift is observable in the rhetoric that portrays dictatorships as stable and orderly while characterizing democracies as chaotic and divided. Such messaging, which resonates with certain groups in the West, is amplified by both domestic and foreign actors who seek to undermine democratic institutions. The interplay of these narratives poses a significant threat to the integrity of democratic societies, prompting a reevaluation of the values that have historically underpinned Western governance.
Anne is a journalist and historian. She’s currently a staff writer at The Atlantic and a senior fellow at Johns Hopkins University’s Agora Institute. She’s written many books, including Red Famine, Gulag: A History, and Twilight of Democracy, and her new one is Autocracy, Inc: The Dictators Who Want to Run the World. Also check her substack, “Open Letters.”
For two clips of our convo — on whether Trump is a kleptocrat, and whether Kamala can connect with the public — pop over to our YouTube page. Other topics: the ways dictatorships no longer act alone; surveillance and social media; the appeal of Western freedoms via the internet; the Great Firewall; the Uyghurs and squelching dissent before it happens — with algorithms; Iranian theocracy; how autocrats have anonymity but their subjects don’t; the ease of stealing and hiding money; shell corporations; the unipolar hegemon of the US; the influence-peddling of the Trumps and the Bidens; what frightens Anne most about Trump; how his China policy could disappoint hawks; why he admires dictators; J.D. Vance and isolationism; Putin invading Ukraine to test the West; the failure of sanctions to cripple Russia; its economic alliance with China; Dubya’s foreign adventures; a dictator’s appeal to order and tradition; the profound brutality of Stalin; the Cold War; the war in Syria stoked by Russia; the fall of Venezuela as a rich democracy; Western democracies in crisis today; mass migration and Biden’s failure; the turnover of Tory PMs and Starmer’s “stability”; the West’s goal of transparency and accountability; autocrats leaning into social conservatism; scapegoating gays; the myth of Russia as a white Christian nation; misinformation and free speech; Trump’s endurance; the assassination attempt; and Anne’s husband becoming the foreign minister of Poland.
Browse the Dishcast archive for an episode you might enjoy (the first 102 are free in their entirety — subscribe to get everything else). Coming up: Jeffrey Toobin on the Supreme Court, Eric Kaufmann on reversing woke extremism, and Bill Wasik and Monica Murphy on animal cruelty. (Van Jones’ PR team canceled his planned appearance.) Please send any guest recs, dissents, and other comments to dish@andrewsullivan.com.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode