Misconceptions about digital asset tax compliance are common. With business tax returns now requiring taxpayers to affirm their taxable digital asset transactions, it is even more important to ask the right questions. Educating yourself and your clients in this area is important to fulfill your due diligence requirements as a tax practitioner.

AICPA resources

•  Digital assets and virtual currency tax guidance and resources —This hub is your go-to library for AICPA guidance and resources as well as current legislation, IRS initiatives and tax advocacy projects.  
•  Questionnaire for Individual Clients — Before accepting clients that are engaged in digital asset activities, there are certain questions CPA practitioners should have answers to.

Advocacy

• AICPA comments on the proposed Sec. 6045 regulations on gross proceeds and basis reporting by brokers, Nov. 8, 2023
• AICPA comments in response to the July 11, 2023, Senate Finance Committee letter on taxation of digital assets, Sept. 8, 2023   
• AICPA comments on the IRS draft 2023 tax forms digital asset question, July 28, 2023

Other resources 

• IRS Digital Assets  — Resources and guidance available on the IRS.gov website

Transcript

On today's podcast, listen to hear more about how you need to carefully ask your clients about their digital asset activity.

April Walker: Hello everyone, and welcome to the AICPA's tax section Odyssey Podcast, where we offer thought leadership on all things tax facing the profession.

I'm April Walker, a lead manager from the tax section, and I'm here today with Nik Fahrer. He's a senior manager at FORVIS in their National Tax Professional Standards Group. He's been with us before talking about this topic, and I'm delighted to have you back, Nik.

Nik Fahrer: Thank you for having me back, April. I'm excited to be here.

Walker: You are our digital asset expert on the podcast. No pressure. We're going to delve into some questions that [are centered around that] here we are in February and we're getting ready to start talking to our clients. We're going to talk a little bit about that. I feel like the more I learn about digital assets, they have different names- cryptocurrency, virtual assets, the more I need to learn.

Hopefully today we're going to help you be able to have a conversation with your clients. Maybe your client is more knowledgeable than you are or you just need to get up to speed. That's our focus for today.

I'd like to start with what are your most common misconceptions that you encounter about digital asset tax compliance when you're thinking about working with clients?

Fahrer: Sure. I really like to break this down into four different categories. I think the first category is, do we have a taxable event? There's a big common misconception out there, especially with clients, that maybe there needs to be some education and educating our clients. That just because you invest in crypto and perform some trades, but haven't settled back to US dollars, doesn't necessarily mean that you don't have a taxable event.

Let's take an example. Let's say I buy some Bitcoin and then I trade that Bitcoin directly for Etherium, then I trade that Etherium directly for Solana. There's multiple taxable events in there because the IRS treats cryptocurrency as property. Even though I haven't settled back to US dollars and cashed out, a lot of clients think, I haven't traded my crypto back into US dollars, so I don't have to report it on my tax return. That's actually false. Those trades in that example, from Bitcoin to Etherium, that's a taxable event, and then from Etherium to Solana, another taxable event.

The second bucket, I would say here is completeness, so really making sure that we have all of our sources and transactions accounted for. What do I mean by that?

Another example, if you have a client that comes to you and says, hey, I transacted in crypto in 2023 and I need help reporting that. Clearly identifying what were all of the exchanges that they used, what were all of the wallets that they used, and does that account for all of their transactions. Like we just mentioned in the previous bucket, do we have a taxable event?

Almost every single transaction in the space is going to be a taxable event. We have to make sure that we can account for all of those and have the proper records. It can be difficult to track them all down because it's so easy to just open up a new wallet.

Third bucket, I would say, is understanding the character of the gain or loss. I mentioned earlier the IRS says this is treated as property. That doesn't necessarily mean that all of the transactions are capital gain or loss, some of them could be ordinary.

Some examples would be mining income, staking income, air drops, hard forks. All of these in the eyes of the IRS are likely considered ordinary income at the fair market value at the time of receipt.

One question you want to make sure that you're asking your clients is, not only can you give me list of your transactions of trades, but you also want to make sure that you're getting a list of transactions for some of these ordinary income items, which may be listed separately.

A lot of times our clients are using a software provider to generate a [Form] 8949. Well, those ordinary transactions aren't necessarily going to be captured on that [Form] 8949 because that [Form] 8949 is going to be your capital gain or loss.

Second, within this third bucket of the character of the gain or loss of NFTs, the IRS has come out and said that, are likely treated as collectibles and those could be subject to a higher tax rate as well. We want to make sure that we are capturing those NFT's and marking the appropriate box and letter associated letter on the [Form] 8949.

The fourth bucket, and I would say this one probably gets looked over the most, is are there any additional surtaxes associated with the client's activity? For example, net investment income tax. A lot of our clients are not CPAs, they're not accountants [and] are not aware of this may be additional tax that their capital gain or loss may be subject to. It's making sure that we're having these conversations with them so that they're aware that the max capital gain rate is 20%, but may be subject to this net investment income tax, which is an additional 3.8%. That's important when we're thinking through estimated tax payments, things like that.

Of course, there's self-employment tax if you're in the trade or business of mining or staking, for example, and that could be up to 15.3%. Then the additional Medicare tax of an additional 0.9% on maybe the net self-employment earnings associated with mining or staking or some of these other activities.

Just to recap, the four buckets that I would really say are, one, making sure that we identify all of the taxable events. Two, completeness. Making sure that we have all of our activity in some sort of Excel spreadsheet or [Form] 8949 that's generated from a software. Number 3, what's the character of the gain or loss? Doesn't necessarily mean it's always going to be capital. Could be ordinary. Then four, what additional taxes may be applicable as well? Net investment income tax, self-employment tax, additional Medicare tax, things like that.

Walker: Thanks Nik. That's super helpful. Definitely things I've heard too and probably misconceptions that I have as I'm still learning and try to understand and wrap my head around these topics and how the IRS treat digital assets compliance.

Another thing I wanted to bring up, and you've likely seen it, the IRS just did an announcement about it. We've talked for several years — I should have gone back and looked and seen how many years there has been a digital asset question on the 1040.

But, in addition to that, they've tweaked the language throughout time. But in addition to the 1040, there's also now that same digital asset question about, did you receive sell, or exchange or otherwise dispose of a digital asset? Those are going to be on business returns and also trust returns for 2023.

Just thinking about that, how are you thinking about getting that information from clients? Probably the same situation as you have been already for individuals. But any tips and tricks on navigating those questions that might be new for people?

Fahrer: I think this is a very important topic because that question is subject to penalties of perjury. So we want to make sure that we're probably erring on the side of caution and making sure that we're capturing this information from our clients.

One thing that we do is we add this question to our client questionnaires. Every single one of our clients fills out a questionnaire, and we word it almost verbatim to the question on the 1040, and now these other forms that you mentioned. Did you essentially transact in digital assets? I'm oversimplifying it, but that's basically what it's asking. Put that question on your client questionnaires and that's a really easy way to get that information from your clients.

Maybe another suggestion is consider adding this as a question to your client acceptance process as well. When you're first going through the process of having conversations with clients or whatever that intake process looks for you and your firm, consider adding that as a question to your client acceptance process.

Then I always recommend getting ahead of it as well. Get a good idea of the types of records that your clients can provide on the front end. This goes back to client acceptance as well. Good records go a long way whenever we're talking about reporting digital asset activity.

If a client can't provide you with good records, or maybe for example, they provide you a spreadsheet with hundreds or thousands of transactions and you have to go in there and manually calculate cost, basis, and proceeds. It's very time intensive, very costly, and that's going to help you understand what to quote them on fees. It may also help you push them in direction of maybe trying to sign up for a software like a CoinTracker or Ledgible or Cryptio, or Koinly.

There's several different softwares in the market where clients can go out there and connect their wallets, connect their exchanges and it will do a really good job of summarizing almost all of the activity on your behalf and generate [a Form] 8949, generate supporting schedules and things like that. Most of the time you're going to run into scenarios where there's software, it's an extra expense, but it's going to more than cover its cost to save you all the headache and time that you're going to have to calculate everything manually.

Walker: Definitely, some unique challenges in tracking and reporting digital assets as opposed to if somebody is just holding securities or mutual funds in a brokerage account, that's pretty easy. There can be some complicated transactions in there, but it's not the same thing as digital assets.

Then, like you said, there's so many different, usually if they're transacting, it's going to be a large number of transactions, that Excel spreadsheet could look like a nightmare, I would imagine. Any best practices or strategies or tips, and you mentioned some softwares and things, when do you see that a client has made the flip from I can just track this in an Excel spreadsheet to needing software?

Fahrer: Yeah, that's a really good point.

Maybe to add some context to why we even have these Excel spreadsheets. [Form] 1099 reporting is not currently required for crypto transactions. Typically clients get to 1099B at the end of the year for their stocks and securities. Those transactions are all summarized for us and it’s super easy as a practitioner to then take that information and transfer it to the tax return.

Whereas here there is no [Form] 1099. Maybe going back to the misconceptions that we talked about earlier, another misconception is that a receipt of a [Form] 1099 triggers the tax reporting requirement. Most of us know that's not true. It's not the receipt of the 1099 that triggers the reporting requirement, it's the taxable event itself, but our clients may not be aware of that. That's why it's even more prudent to ask these questions on the front end of, did you transact in digital assets, to get a better understanding of what all needs to go into the return?

I also think that self custody is something that's unique to this industry, if you will. We have the concept of you control your own assets means that there may not be a third party intermediary. There may not be a broker to keep track of your cost basis, and then that burden falls on the taxpayer. If the taxpayer is unable to provide records or proof of cost basis, the IRS is going to assume it's zero, which is the worst case scenario.

But to go back to your question April and really answer it more directly, I think if you have a client that has more than 20 transactions in a single year, it's probably worth it to work through one of those softwares that I mentioned before to get them to sign up for that, connect their wallets, their exchanges, and hopefully bring in everything in one central location and automate a lot of it.

Then I think there's some good resources out there too on how to stay up to date and understand maybe some changes that are going on in the industry. We have an AICPA web page that's dedicated to this topic. It's a very good resource.

There's also a questionnaire on that web page that you can download. It goes through and is basically built for practitioners to know what questions to ask. We don't know what we don't know if you're not in the space. This is a great questionnaire to go out there and just cherry pick what you think would be beneficial to ask your clients. This is a resource for you.

The IRS also has a website that is specifically dedicated to digital assets. If you just google IRS digital assets, I'm almost fairly certain it's going to be one of the first ones that pops up. It has all of the guidance that they've ever issued in this one single web page. Then of course, there's several people that are very vocal on LinkedIn and Twitter [X] that you can follow and good resources there as well.

Walker: Perfect. Thank you for highlighting those resources. The questionnaire is what spurred wanting to have this discussion. Nik actually did a few videos for us on the website related to that questionnaire, and we wanted to dig a little deeper. In the show notes I'll put a link to our digital asset page and that's going to have that questionnaire as well as like you said, other resources, it also links to the IRS.

One thing I wanted to note is the IRS does do I think a good job of [what] you might just be struggling with, hey, that question [on the tax return] — How do I answer it? Is there a way for me to answer no? There probably is an answer. I think we discussed this, but I wanted to say you have to answer that question. If we didn't say that specifically [earlier], I wanted to say that you have to say yes or no.

The IRS provides ways that you must check the box yes, if they did this- received digital assets for payment or digital assets for this or that. Then it also tells you a couple scenarios for no. Again, I'll put link to those resources in the show notes linked to the questionnaire. Which is great, especially if you have clients who are really in this space.

I wanted to share that Nik is on a Digital Asset Tax Task Force with the AICPA. That is a mouthful that I had to say very slowly. So thank you, Nik for doing that. I have a couple of other members of that task force and we're going to do some follow ups.

Nik referenced that there is no 1099 for digital assets you may be aware about. There are some reporting requirements that are coming in future years that we're going to have somebody who's going to talk about that. We're also going to talk about what happens for digital assets if you've experienced a loss. There's some tricky tax rules related to that. Just wanted to give a little bit of a teaser for that coming up.

Nik, you provided a lot of great information. I'd just like to give you an opportunity, is there any final thoughts as you're thinking about this topic or any good advice for our practitioners that are listening.

Fahrer: I just want to say thanks again for having me, April. We have a saying at FORVIS, if you see risk seek help. I would just encourage our listeners. If you come across a client where there may be some complex situations with digital assets, don't hesitate to reach out to somebody in your network that may be able to help you. It's very ambiguous right now, we don't have a ton of guidance and I would just encourage you to reach out to those in your network that may be able to help.

Walker: Perfect. In closing on these podcasts, I like to think about us taking a journey together towards a better profession. In doing that, I'd like to hear about my guest other journeys outside of the world of tax. Nik, I'd love to hear a page from your travel journey bucket list or a memorable trip that is on your mind.

Fahrer: I'm actually really excited to travel to Alaska for the first time this upcoming May. Really excited about that trip.

Walker: Nice. Are you doing a cruise or just exploring around in Alaska?

Fahrer: Yeah. Just flying into Anchorage and then renting a car and trying to explore as much of it as possible as part of the shoulder season. Not everything will be necessarily open yet. I really want to make it to Denali, but we'll see.

Walker: Okay. We'll have to follow back up on another podcast that will, sorry, probably be about digital assets, but I appreciate you being able to talk about it in such an understandable way. Thank you again, Nik.

Again, this is April Walker from the AICPA tax section. This community is your go to source for technical guidance and resources designed especially for CPA tax practitioners like you and mind. This is a podcast from AICPA and CIMA together as the Association of International Certified Professional Accounts. You can find us wherever you listen to your podcast. We encourage you to follow us so you don't miss an episode. If you already follow us, thank you so much and please feel free to share it with a like minded friend. You can also find us at aicpa-cima.com/tax and find other episodes as well as get access to all the resources that we mentioned a lot on this episode. Thank you so much for listening.