Michelle Goldberg, an opinion columnist for the New York Times and MSNBC contributor, shares her journey from a conservative upbringing in Buffalo to becoming a vocal advocate for progressive causes. She passionately discusses her experiences during the Buffalo abortion wars and critiques the complex political strategies of figures like Kamala Harris and Joe Biden. The conversation dives into America's cultural grievances, the radicalization of the left post-Trump, and the shifting standards of political integrity, offering insightful commentary on current societal divisions.
Michelle Goldberg reflects on her conservative upbringing in Buffalo, which significantly shaped her progressive ideologies and activism, particularly around abortion rights.
Goldberg critiques the political landscape's evolving dynamics, emphasizing how candidates like Kamala Harris grapple with authenticity and public expectations amid changing societal grievances.
Deep dives
The Evolution of Political Identity
Michelle Goldberg reflects on her upbringing in Buffalo, New York, where her family's political inclinations and the cultural climate shaped her early views. Growing up in a conservative environment, she felt a sense of rebellion that pushed her towards more progressive ideologies. She discusses her engagement in social issues during her youth, particularly her involvement in the pro-choice movement amid the Buffalo abortion wars, which profoundly influenced her political stance. This early activism introduced her to the complexities of advocacy and dissent, setting the stage for her future career as a journalist and columnist.
Career Path to Journalism
Goldberg's journey to becoming an opinion columnist was marked by early reluctance, stemming from her father's background as a journalist. Despite her initial desire to become a novelist, she soon recognized the practicality of journalism for making a living as a writer. After graduating college at a young age, she quickly established her career in journalism, exposing herself to various political landscapes and cultural discussions. Her early professional experiences, particularly covering the dynamics of the 2004 presidential election, would further sharpen her insights on the evolving political landscape in America.
Anatomy of Political Campaigns
In discussing the current political campaigns, Goldberg critiques the unique challenges faced by candidates like Kamala Harris, highlighting the implications of not undergoing a traditional primary process. She notes that lacking campaign experience can hinder authenticity in candidates as they navigate public expectations and political positioning. The tensions between previous campaign statements and present realities are explored, illustrating how candidates must adapt their narratives in a rapidly changing political landscape. Goldberg emphasizes the importance of candidate clarity, as shifts in stance can lead to perceived inauthenticity, affecting public perception and trust.
Cultural Grievances and Political Discontent
Throughout the conversation, Goldberg addresses the cultural grievances that have become increasingly prominent in contemporary politics, noting how they resonate with many voters. She explains that many individuals, once aligned with Democratic ideals, now find themselves drawn to figures like Trump due to a sense of disenfranchisement and discontent with established institutions. This shift reflects deeper societal fissures, including reactions to social movements and issues like immigration. Goldberg argues that addressing these grievances and understanding their roots is crucial for building a more inclusive and effective political dialogue moving forward.
Michelle is an opinion columnist at the New York Times, and before that she was a columnist for Slate. She has written three books: Kingdom Coming: The Rise of Christian Nationalism, The Means of Reproduction, and The Goddess Pose. She’s also an on-air contributor at MSNBC.
For two clips of our convo — debating who the real Kamala is, and how much BLM is responsible for lost black lives — pop over to our YouTube page. Other topics: growing up in Buffalo with conservative parents; her dad a journalist and mom a math teacher; Michelle a teen activist in the “Buffalo abortion wars”; the legality but ugliness of clinic protests; a pro-life man knocking the wind out of her; ACT UP; going to J-school; reporting at mega-churches in Ohio in the 2004 election; Harris’ moderate Smart on Crime book in 2009; her “triangulating” in 2019 (e.g. fracking); her busing moment with Biden; supporting a bail fund in summer 2020; Biden’s bait-and-switch as a centrist; bipartisan support for Israel; Merrick Garland’s effort to appear apolitical; lawfare; from Bush’s “f**k yeah” patriotism to Trump’s dark view of America; the Iraq War and 2008 bailout causing mistrust toward institutions; crumbling infrastructure; Trump never being a majority candidate; the cultural grievance fueling him; Michelle going to Trump rallies; the 1619 Project; debating the US as a “white supremacy”; the left radicalizing after Trump replaced a two-term black president; Covid mania; the distortion of Twitter; the Electoral College and its roots; the violent crime spike in 2020 and after; how the disadvantaged always bear the brunt of disorder; the greed of BLM Inc; the press distortion of unarmed black men killed by police; Michelle’s 2014 piece “What Is a Woman?”; Rachel Levine; puberty blockers; the Dutch protocol; the Cass Review; bathroom bills; and the GLAAD protest against the NYT.
Browse the Dishcast archive for an episode you might enjoy (the first 102 are free in their entirety — subscribe to get everything else). Coming up: David Frum on Trump, Musa al-Gharbi on wokeness, Walter Kirn on Republican voters, Bill Wasik and Monica Murphy on animal welfare, Mary Matalin on life, Anderson Cooper on grief, John Gray on, well, everything, and Sam Harris for our quadrennial chat before Election Day. Please send any guest recs, dissents, and other comments to dish@andrewsullivan.com.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode