Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford Homo deceptus: Science's Dirty Little Secret
58 snips
Nov 28, 2025 A fossil discovery in 1912, once hailed as a missing link, turns out to be one of science's biggest hoaxes. Tim Harford delves into the strange anatomy of Piltdown Man, blending human and ape traits. The investigation reveals a shocking scale of deception, with multiple fakes uncovered. Suspects are scrutinized, particularly the dubious practices of Charles Dawson. The discussion ties historical fraud to modern-day issues in research, emphasizing the critical need for truth in science.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
The Piltdown Discovery Letter
- Charles Dawson wrote to Arthur Woodward about a fossil fragment found at Piltdown that he claimed was human.
- Their collaboration led to the celebrated but later-discredited Piltdown Man discovery that misled science for decades.
Weiner's Hands-On Doubts
- Joseph Weiner examined Piltdown casts and saw odd tooth wear and superficial staining that suggested tampering.
- His experiments filing an ape tooth revealed how easily the forgeries could be produced and prompted scientific re-evaluation.
Simple Forgeries, Massive Consequences
- Chemical dating and microscopic tests proved the Piltdown skull, jaw and teeth were modern and artificially stained.
- The collective simplicity of each forgery produced a devastatingly convincing overall deception.
