The Dreyfus Affair highlighted deep-rooted anti-Semitism in France, revealing societal divisions exacerbated by post-war nationalism and scapegoating.
Zola's 'J'accuse' transformed the Dreyfus trial into a public spectacle, illustrating the media's influence on societal narratives and political discourse.
Deep dives
The Origins of the Dreyfus Affair
The Dreyfus Affair began in the 1890s when military intelligence in France, aiming to bolster security against Germany, suspected Alfred Dreyfus, a Jewish artillery officer, of espionage. A charwoman working in the German embassy uncovered a note indicating betrayal, leading the military to target Dreyfus despite flimsy evidence. His background as an Alsatian Jew speaking with a German accent contributed to the suspicion against him, reflecting existing anti-Semitic sentiments in France. The trial that followed culminated in a court-martial where Dreyfus was found guilty and sent to Devil’s Island, highlighting the deeply entrenched biases within the French military and society.
The Role of Anti-Semitism and Public Sentiment
The Dreyfus Affair exposed rampant anti-Semitism in France, which became particularly pronounced in the context of post-war national discontent and scapegoating during the rise of populism. The betrayal of 1870-71, when France lost Alsace and Lorraine to Germany, fostered a sense of wounded patriotism, leading many to irrationally blame Jews for national failures. Media figures like Émile Zola would become pivotal in pushing back against the anti-Dreyfusard sentiment, yet the backlash showcased how deeply divided public opinion was. This societal fracture gave rise to a broader discourse about Frenchness and nationalism, influencing not only the trial but the political landscape over the following decades.
Zola's Intervention and Escalation of the Affair
Zola's open letter 'J'accuse' marked a critical turning point in the Dreyfus Affair, transforming it from a military trial into a sensational public quandary. This letter ignited widespread debate and ultimately led to Zola facing his own trial for defamation, reinforcing the affair's status as a cultural battleground. His actions galvanized supporters of Dreyfus and drew the attention of the public, demonstrating the power of media in shaping societal narratives at the time. Yet, the military retained its determination to maintain Dreyfus's guilt, resulting in ongoing divisions and escalations that would stretch on for years.
Long-Term Consequences and Legacy
The Dreyfus Affair had lasting implications for France, influencing its political, social, and constitutional landscape well into the 20th century. It played a significant role in the separation of church and state, reflecting the broader conflict between secular and religious values within French society. The unresolved tensions surrounding the case also inspired Jewish thinkers like Theodor Herzl to advocate for Zionism as a solution to pervasive anti-Semitism, suggesting a movement toward a state of self-determination for Jews. The affair ultimately serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of prejudice and the complexities of justice, with its legacy still reverberating in contemporary discussions of civil rights and national identity.
It started with an inconsequential piece of military intelligence, scrawled on a piece of paper and left in a waste paper basket. But over the next decade, the infamous Dreyfus affair would mutate into a scandal that shook nineteenth-century France and stunned the world.
Ruth Harris is a Professor of History at the University of Oxford and author of 'The Man on Devil's Island'. She joins us to explain what a Jewish artillery officer's wrongful conviction tells us about the deep divisions within French society, and explains its long-lasting implications for modern nationalism and even the Zionist movement.
Produced by James Hickmann and edited by Dougal Patmore.
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
