Talk of the Devils: The Athletic FC's Manchester United show Questions over Amorim return after Everton defeat
9 snips
Nov 25, 2025 In a shocking twist, Everton became the first team to win at Old Trafford after a red card. The hosts analyze the bizarre incident and United's inability to capitalize on their numerical advantage. Questions arise about Amorim’s tactical rigidity and the stark contrast to last season's performances. With player intensity under scrutiny, the discussion shifts to bench depth and squad limitations. They contemplate whether new transfers can mend tactical flaws, all while acknowledging the emotional atmosphere at the stadium.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Possession Didn't Translate To Pressure
- Manchester United failed to capitalise on Everton's red card and lacked sustained final-third pressure despite dominating possession.
- The team's change in average positions and use of a deeper Joshua Zerkazi disrupted the expected attacking stretch.
System Blunted Numerical Advantage
- The back-three system reduced the numerical advantage when Everton went down to ten and made overloads less obvious.
- United's first half was described as dreadful, showing structural issues beyond individual errors.
Intensity Regression Raised Alarms
- Ruben Amorim publicly questioned his players' intensity after the game, suggesting a mental and physical regression.
- The team showed signs of reverting to last season's bad habits despite earlier improvement.