Talk of the Devils: The Athletic FC's Manchester United show

Andy Mitten, longtime United correspondent; Carl Anka, football writer with stats insight; Laurie Whitwell, tactical analyst. They debate whether Fulham will truly test Carrick. They dissect Fulham’s physical threat, Dorgu’s hamstring absence, left‑side fitness, defensive shape and squad leadership questions. Short, sharp conversations on tactics, replacements and looming transfer choices.

They debate whether Michael Carrick should be the permanent manager and name realistic external candidates. Tactical balance of the coaching setup and Steve Holland's defensive influence get close attention. Squad selection topics include the left‑footed front three and goalkeeper Sanna Lamprou's form. They also weigh Kobbie Mainoo's World Cup chances and revisit outrageous preseason predictions.

Andy Mitten, longtime Manchester United journalist offering seasoned club perspective. Carl Anka, feature writer bringing lively match reaction and narrative punch. Laurie Whitwell, tactical analyst breaking down player roles and decisions. They rave about Dorgu’s wonder-strike and Cunha’s super-sub impact. They unpack Carrick’s calming influence, selection choices and whether United’s recent run puts them in contention for Champions League football.

Join Carl Anka, a tactical ace and journalist for The Athletic, alongside Andy Mitten, an insightful Manchester United writer, as they dissect the club's current state. They explore Michael Carrick's transformative impact on team morale and management clarity. With Arsenal looming, the duo evaluate United's transfer strategy, focusing on potential loan moves and youthful prospects. They also delve into United's challenging history at the Emirates and the pressing need to tackle set-piece threats effectively. Will United rise to the occasion?

Laurie Whitwell, a football journalist known for his strategic insights, Carl Anka, a senior writer focused on fan perspectives, and Andy Mitten, a seasoned United correspondent, dissect an electrifying Manchester Derby win. They delve into standout performances, with Bruno Fernandes and Casemiro shining in pivotal roles. The panel explores Michael Carrick's effective management, the players' responses to media scrutiny, and the implications for the club's future. Can this level of intensity be sustained as United aims for European football?

Michael Carrick's new role as head coach brings high hopes for Manchester United, but he faces a tough challenge against Manchester City right away. Fans express anger towards ownership, highlighting the need for accountability. The hosts explore Carrick’s tactical successes at Middlesbrough and discuss his strategies for integrating returning players. They also delve into the importance of qualifying for the Champions League and how it impacts the club financially and in terms of reputation. Can United turn the mood around at Old Trafford?

Laurie Whitwell, a football journalist for The Athletic with deep expertise in Manchester United, joins the discussion on the club's recent turmoil. They delve into Michael Carrick's candidacy as interim manager, exploring his past successes and club knowledge. The conversation touches on Darren Fletcher's brief spell in charge and the potential for increased reliance on heritage within the club. The panel also critiques the disappointing FA Cup exit and discusses the emotional atmosphere at Old Trafford, highlighting the challenges ahead.

Manchester United finds itself in a dilemma after sacking Ruben Amorim, with Darren Fletcher stepping in for the FA Cup match. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has shown interest in returning, but would that be a step backward? The panel debates the merits of interim versus permanent management, while also critiquing the club's decision-making and recruitment under Ineos. Amidst the turmoil, standout performances like Benjamin Sesko's two goals and missed chances from Shea Lacey highlight the team's struggles in a tightly packed Premier League.

Manchester United has sacked Ruben Amorim, marking a tumultuous end to his 18-month reign. Youth team manager Darren Fletcher steps in as interim coach. The decision was described as reluctant, with tensions over transfers and tactics contributing to Amorim’s downfall. Public criticism may have also played a role in his dismissal. The hosts explore Fletcher's potential tactical shifts and what this means for the team's European ambitions, while assessing Amorim's mixed legacy. There's a pressing need for the board to find the right replacement.

The discussion dives into a tense draw against Leeds, highlighting the absence of key players. Ruben Amorim's cryptic comments about transfers raise eyebrows, hinting at unrest. The panel interrogates his flat demeanor and refusal to confirm tactical changes during press conferences. Key moments from the match are reviewed, including Joshua Zerkzy's impact. As the team looks ahead to Burnley, urgency builds with the need for a vital win and potential returns for injured stars.