Talk of the Devils: The Athletic FC's Manchester United show

Join football experts Carl Anka, Andy Mitten, and Mark Critchley as they dissect Manchester United's recent downturn after a shocking loss to Everton. The trio debates the fairness of criticism directed at manager Ruben Amorim, while laying out the team's current standing and realistic expectations for the season. They play a humorous 'would you rather' game before gearing up for the challenge against a reinvigorated Crystal Palace. In a tactical breakdown, they also consider lineup options and the impact of midweek fatigue on performances.

This week, the panel dives into the impact of January transfer rumors as a silver lining amid recent frustrations. They imagine a fantasy dinner party with past and present United stars, exploring their intriguing personalities. The discussion shifts to youth player opportunities, with hopes for a revamped scouting approach. Stadium regeneration plans spark debates over finances and completion timelines. The team also tackles training ground stories, past feuds, and their greatest match memories, intertwining history with current challenges.

In a shocking twist, Everton became the first team to win at Old Trafford after a red card. The hosts analyze the bizarre incident and United's inability to capitalize on their numerical advantage. Questions arise about Amorim’s tactical rigidity and the stark contrast to last season's performances. With player intensity under scrutiny, the discussion shifts to bench depth and squad limitations. They contemplate whether new transfers can mend tactical flaws, all while acknowledging the emotional atmosphere at the stadium.

Laurie Whitwell, an Athletic journalist who recently reported from Jamaica, shares thrilling insights about the international football drama. He describes the electrifying atmosphere of Jamaica's nil-nil match and reflects on the implications of Benjamin Sesko's absence for Manchester United's attack. The discussion also touches on potential replacements like Joshua Zirkzee and the challenges facing the women's team. Plus, consider how Everton's weaknesses could be exploited as United looks to build momentum before the busy December fixtures.

In this discussion, Charlotte Harper, a women's sport reporter for The Athletic, dives into the highs and lows of Manchester United Women. She highlights their impressive Champions League victory over PSG, but also the disappointing defeat in the Manchester derby, raising concerns about squad depth. With key players like Fallon Tullis-Joyce sidelined, Charlotte examines their resilience ahead of a challenging match against Wolfsburg and discusses the team's prospects as they approach a packed fixture list in both domestic and European competitions.

Ruben Amorim's swift hiring by Manchester United after Erik Ten Hag's dismissal sparked intrigue. The panel delves into the recruitment process and initial achievements under Amorim, highlighting his adaptation amid tough challenges. Discussions reveal his unique management style, particularly in connecting with younger players. The coaches also evaluate how a Europa League defeat may have shifted the club's trajectory. As a year unfolds, expectations for success and future progress are thoughtfully explored.

Keris Jones, a Football writer for The Athletic, joins to discuss Manchester United Women's pressing fixtures and the impact of the recent loss against Aston Villa. The panel reflects on the significance of the upcoming Champions League game against PSG and the mixed reception awaiting the returning Mary Earps. Jones emphasizes the team's noticeable changes under manager Mark Skinner and raises concerns about squad depth amid a challenging schedule. There's also a debate on the importance of reinforcements if they aim for progress this season.

The crew discusses Manchester United's upcoming match against Spurs and the challenges of breaking through a low block defense. Insights from Jonny Evans' TV appearance spark debates about media openness. They analyze United's tactics under Ruben Amorim and the importance of scoring first for success this season. The team's recent struggles at Tottenham are weighed against a possible vengeance for last year's defeats. Plus, training ground improvements at Carrington and player recruitment philosophies add depth to the conversation.

November brings optimism for Manchester United under Ruben Amorim. The hosts discuss the impact of being out of Europe and how it aids player recovery. They analyze the Premier League's open landscape and United's top-four ambitions. The emotional challenge of reporting bad news as fans is a notable topic. Midfield reinforcement is favored for January transfers, and there's speculation about Casemiro's contract extension. The exciting potential of academy talents also gets the spotlight.

Manchester United rallied for a thrilling 2-2 draw against Nottingham Forest, with Amad Diallo scoring a stunning volley. The team debated if this was a point gained or two dropped after a chaotic collapse post-half-time. Casemiro’s solid performance and tactical discussions highlight their improvement compared to last season. Concerns about potential key player absences during AFCON prompt a look at their tactical options. The panel also weighs in on pressing transfer needs and the effectiveness of Amorim's attacking philosophy.