

Talk of the Devils: The Athletic FC's Manchester United show
The Athletic
Host Ian Irving is joined by The Athletic's Laurie Whitwell, Carl Anka and Andy Mitten on the world's biggest Manchester United podcast. Subscribe for expert insight from inside the club, breaking news and two episodes every week. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Episodes
Mentioned books

Dec 18, 2025 • 58min
Is Bruno Fernandes irreplaceable at Man United?
The podcast dives into Bruno Fernandes' revealing interview, sparking debate about his future at Manchester United. The panel evaluates his irreplaceable role amidst the looming AFCON absences. They discuss how the team plans to cope without key players and explore potential midfield transfers. Attention turns to the upcoming clash with Aston Villa, analyzing their tactical strengths and potential threats. Defensive woes and the women's team's Champions League progress also take the spotlight, promising an exciting analysis!

Dec 16, 2025 • 1h 2min
Man United’s mad 4-4 draw: a full breakdown
What a thrilling rollercoaster ride! Manchester United showcased a dazzling attacking display, led by Cunha and Bruno Fernandes, but defensive lapses allowed Bournemouth to equalize three times. The discussion dives into the tactical changes introduced by Ruben Amorim and contrasts the attacking flare with persistent defensive issues. Excitement in the air at Old Trafford raises questions about sustainable improvement. Plus, insights on youth development and the season's unpredictable nature keep the conversation engaging!

Dec 11, 2025 • 54min
What does Mainoo’s situation say about modern Man United?
Laurie Whitwell, Manchester United correspondent for The Athletic, Carl Anka, a seasoned tactical analyst, and Andy Mitten, a longtime football journalist, dive into Kobbie Mainoo's uncertain future at United. They discuss whether he should be loaned out for more playing time and the challenges he faces in fitting into the current system. The panel also highlights young talent JJ Gabriel's impressive performances in the FA Youth Cup, pondering if he can live up to his idol Neymar. They further explore the changing landscape of United's academy amidst ongoing scrutiny.

Dec 9, 2025 • 48min
Man United win emphatically at Wolves after wobble
Laurie Whitwell, a football journalist for The Athletic, and Andy Mitten, a seasoned Manchester United pundit, dive into United's impressive 4-1 victory over Wolves. They discuss the significance of Mason Mount's standout performance and dive into the team's fragile confidence following recent struggles. With intriguing insights on fan reactions, tactical tweaks, and the ongoing impact of Johnny Evans' departure, the duo offers a mix of analysis and light-hearted moments. The episode wraps with a look ahead to an exciting FA Cup draw against Brighton.

Dec 5, 2025 • 44min
Why have Man United missed another opportunity at Old Trafford?
Joined by Andy Mitten, an experienced journalist focused on Manchester United, and Carl Anka, a sharp football analyst, the discussion centers on United's frustrating 1-1 draw against West Ham. They dive into the impact of defensive frailties on the team's performance and the controversial substitutions made by manager Ruben Amorim. The duo also debates the potential of young midfielder Kobbie Mainoo and the club's current youth integration, alongside sharing anecdotes about Remi Moses' legacy within United's history.

Dec 1, 2025 • 54min
Mount and Zirkzee lead Man United comeback
Manchester United pulled off an impressive comeback at Selhurst Park, with Mason Mount shining through a crucial equalizer. The hosts celebrate Bruno Fernandes' two assists, highlighting his impact on United's attacking play. Joshua Zirkzee emerged as a key player, showcasing improved aggression and scoring a rare goal. The episode reflects on United's troubling history at this venue, while the mood shifts to excitement for the upcoming matches. Fans relished the vibrant away-end atmosphere, reminding everyone that winning can silence criticism.

Nov 27, 2025 • 54min
Can Man United bounce back at Palace?
Join football experts Carl Anka, Andy Mitten, and Mark Critchley as they dissect Manchester United's recent downturn after a shocking loss to Everton. The trio debates the fairness of criticism directed at manager Ruben Amorim, while laying out the team's current standing and realistic expectations for the season. They play a humorous 'would you rather' game before gearing up for the challenge against a reinvigorated Crystal Palace. In a tactical breakdown, they also consider lineup options and the impact of midweek fatigue on performances.

Nov 26, 2025 • 44min
Mailbag: Semenyo release clause and Rooney the artist
This week, the panel dives into the impact of January transfer rumors as a silver lining amid recent frustrations. They imagine a fantasy dinner party with past and present United stars, exploring their intriguing personalities. The discussion shifts to youth player opportunities, with hopes for a revamped scouting approach. Stadium regeneration plans spark debates over finances and completion timelines. The team also tackles training ground stories, past feuds, and their greatest match memories, intertwining history with current challenges.

Nov 25, 2025 • 47min
Questions over Amorim return after Everton defeat
In a shocking twist, Everton became the first team to win at Old Trafford after a red card. The hosts analyze the bizarre incident and United's inability to capitalize on their numerical advantage. Questions arise about Amorim’s tactical rigidity and the stark contrast to last season's performances. With player intensity under scrutiny, the discussion shifts to bench depth and squad limitations. They contemplate whether new transfers can mend tactical flaws, all while acknowledging the emotional atmosphere at the stadium.

Nov 20, 2025 • 54min
Man United prepare for a month without Sesko
Laurie Whitwell, an Athletic journalist who recently reported from Jamaica, shares thrilling insights about the international football drama. He describes the electrifying atmosphere of Jamaica's nil-nil match and reflects on the implications of Benjamin Sesko's absence for Manchester United's attack. The discussion also touches on potential replacements like Joshua Zirkzee and the challenges facing the women's team. Plus, consider how Everton's weaknesses could be exploited as United looks to build momentum before the busy December fixtures.


