Business of Sport Ep.32: Brett Johnson, Co-Owner @ Ipswich, Rhode Island FC, & Phoenix Rising ‘The US needs to be more than a retirement league’
Aug 6, 2024
auto_awesome
Brett Johnson, co-owner of Ipswich, Rhode Island FC, and Phoenix Rising, has made significant strides in U.S. football. He discusses the importance of developing soccer franchises beyond the MLS, addressing the financial pressures of attracting young talent. Brett reveals his journey with Phoenix Rising, including the successful acquisition of Didier Drogba and the creation of a new stadium. He also touches on the evolving landscape of U.S. soccer investments and the crucial role innovative strategies play in building a sustainable football culture.
Brett Johnson's ownership journey illustrates the opportunities and challenges in establishing soccer franchises in the U.S. sports landscape.
The crucial role of high-quality stadiums and prime locations is highlighted as key factors for profitability and fan engagement for USL teams.
Despite the allure of star players like Messi, the MLS must attract younger top-tier talent to alter its perception beyond a retirement league.
Deep dives
Lionel Messi's Impact on MLS Perceptions
Signing Lionel Messi is significant for MLS, but it doesn't fully alter the league's perception as a retirement destination for aging stars. Despite attracting casual fans who are willing to pay high prices to see him play, the league still struggles to attract younger top-tier talent. The discussion around whether MLS can truly compete for prime players like Kevin De Bruyne and Erling Haaland reveals a gap in financial capabilities, as they would require extravagant offers to even consider an MLS team. The presence of star players can draw attention, yet without a consistent influx of the world's best talent, the narrative of the league remains limited.
Brett Johnson’s Ownership Journey
Brett Johnson's interest in sports ownership began a decade ago while watching a Major League Soccer match, leading him to pursue ownership in soccer teams. He initially aimed to establish an MLS franchise in Phoenix, driven by the city's demographic potential for soccer. Encountering challenges, he shifted focus to a USL team, initially Arizona United, which eventually became Phoenix Rising. His journey highlights the opportunities and hurdles in soccer ownership, including forming partnerships and navigating league structures.
The Importance of Stadium and Location
Building the right stadium and securing a prime location are critical success factors in team profitability for USL franchises. Johnson faced significant obstacles when his team lost its original stadium lease, forcing them to relocate to a less accessible area, which hindered ticket sales. However, after establishing a new, well-located stadium, the team experienced a turnaround, showcasing the direct impact of venue quality on fan engagement and revenue generation. Successful franchises leverage impressive stadiums to enhance their overall revenue potential, making infrastructure investments essential.
Pathways to Major League Soccer
The USL provides a vital pathway for teams aiming to ascend to Major League Soccer, yet it also faces challenges in the financial landscape. The rising franchise costs for MLS, which have surged from about $60 million to potentially $600 million, makes USL a more accessible option for investors. Johnson emphasizes the sustainability aspect, identifying USL clubs as potential profit generators through ticket sales, merchandise, and player development. The success of USL in nurturing young talent is crucial, as these players can be sold to larger clubs, bringing financial returns.
Future of Soccer in the US
The conversation reflects optimism about the future of soccer in the U.S., particularly with the upcoming World Cup set to boost interest and participation rates. Johnson believes that increased visibility will lead to more talent choosing soccer over traditional American sports, thus enhancing the sport's competitive landscape. The potential for a strong youth soccer culture is evident, as young athletes may aspire to play at high levels, influenced by successful role models in the game. Together with better infrastructure and investment in lower leagues, this growth could fundamentally shift soccer's position in American sports.
This week we’re delighted to welcome Brett Johnson to the show. Brett is the co-owner of Ipswich in the Premier League and Phoenix Rising and Rhode Island in the US. The rise of Ipswich since his group takeover is nothing short of ownership dreamland, seeing the club achieve back to back promotions from League One to the Premier League.
But this is only the most recent success for Brett in football. The joy of speaking to owners on the show is getting access to the people behind the numbers and strategies. Who really are our owners? He has been a key driver of development in the US, building infrastructure, brand and talent in the league under the MLS, the USL. Phoenix Rising has seen huge success over the past decade, from rebrand to new stadium to Didier Drogba, and his new team Rhode Island is set to do great things both on the pitch and in the community.
Sports ownership is one of the most opaque parts of the sports industry. This conversation draws back the curtain. Owners like Brett are what the game needs.
On today’s show we discuss:
Founding franchises:
Identifying opportunity: there are many cities in the US with massive football communities that don’t have an MLS team. What can you create outside of the top system?
How the birth of Phoenix Rising led to the build of a new stadium, development of young talent, and the recruiting of the legendary Didier Drogba as player and part-owner.
Location, Location, Location - these franchises are more than sports teams. They play key roles in the community, from employment to infrastructure/real estate to social value.
Why Rhode Island and what is the opportunity with this new USL franchise?
There is value in the MLS and no one is complaining, but the league needs to become more than a retirement league.
US sports leagues:
Huge value, but limited jeopardy; why it is so hard to facilitate top to bottom relevance in a league season and retain maximum asset value.
What are the buy-in prices for football in the US? It is rumoured that MLS team expansion franchises are now worth $600m. A USL franchise is worth $20m. Which one represents better business?
A deep dive on the USL and why there is so much opportunity from a business perspective and value add from a talent perspective.
How do these businesses run? What are the key revenue streams and how do you ensure you build a business that relies on a strong foundation not fanciful equity valuations.
Ipswich & English football
If you want to be big in football, you need to be in England. This was always Brett’s ambition when becoming a team owner. The next question was which club?
From being approached by Peter Kenyon to buy Newcastle to deciding Ipswich was the club to go after; what were the key factors in buying the club?
Open leagues create the most incredible highs and lowest lows, from both the business side and for the fans. Relegation may decrease value, but rising through the leagues can add hundreds of millions to the value of a club.
The value of English football is so because of the commercial and media revenues it can generate. Can the MLS create that same value without having promotion and relegation, and what is the impact of not doing that?
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode