HPI 43 - We Beg to Differ - the Buddhists and Jains
May 28, 2017
auto_awesome
Learn about the emergence of different philosophical systems in ancient India, the division of Buddhism into rival intellectual schools, the spread of Sābhas Devada and Theravada Buddhism, the Buddhist philosophy of to be relative, and the beliefs and practices of Buddhism, Jainism, and Hindu systems.
Skepticism and syncretism were philosophical responses to the plurality of doctrinal opinions in ancient India, with Buddhism advocating skepticism and Jainism favoring syncretism in an attempt to address the problem.
The development of Buddhist philosophy involved the emergence of rival intellectual schools, such as the Vadas, the exploration of the middle ground between materialism and the Jain theory of self, and the introduction of Mahayana Buddhism with its emphasis on the Bodhisattva ideal and recognition of new Sutra texts.
Deep dives
Response to Philosophical Diversity
The podcast discusses how the great plurality of doctrinal opinions in ancient India became a philosophical problem. Two responses to this problem were explored: skepticism, which claims that there is no justified answer to philosophical questions, and syncretism, which suggests accepting all philosophical positions conditionally. Buddhism, represented by Nagarjuna, advocated skepticism, while Jainism preferred the syncretist approach. Both approaches led to innovations in epistemology and logic in an attempt to avoid self-refutation.
The Development of Buddhist Philosophy
The podcast delves into the development of Buddhist philosophy, particularly after the death of Ashoka in the 3rd century BC. The rival intellectual schools called Vadas emerged within Buddhism, each presenting systematic accounts of their interpretations of Buddhist doctrine. The podcast highlights the central Buddhist tenet that there is no eternal, unchanging self or soul, and explores the middle ground between materialism and Jain theory of self. It also discusses the use of similes by Buddha to express his own view on the self and liberation from bodily existence.
Branches of Mahayana Buddhism
The podcast introduces Mahayana Buddhism, which emphasizes the ideal of the Bodhisattva and other-regarding ethics. Mahayana recognized new Sutra texts as genuine records of the Buddha's teachings and saw Buddha as a functional role rather than an individual person. The Madhyamaka school, found by Nagarjuna, introduced the philosophy of the middle way, while the Yoga Chara school, founded by Asanga and Vasubandhu, focused on psychological and spiritual issues. The podcast briefly mentions subsequent figures and their writings, setting the agenda for future Buddhist philosophy.