Catherine Liu | The Problem With Trauma Culture | HITW 165
Jan 29, 2025
auto_awesome
Catherine Liu, a prominent cultural theorist and author, dives deep into the complexities of trauma culture and its links to the professional-managerial class. She critiques how personal suffering is often commodified, particularly in the context of capitalism. Liu examines historical and contemporary trauma narratives, highlighting the intersection of personal and collective experiences. She also warns against the infantilization in political discourse and advocates for maturity in conversations about trauma, challenging societal norms and the therapeutic industry's limitations.
The Professional Managerial Class has shifted from advocating for workers' rights to aligning with capital, raising concerns about their roles as managers.
Trauma culture commodifies personal suffering for validation, obscuring the collective struggles and broader social contexts of marginalized communities.
Neoliberalism's focus on individualism perpetuates isolation and competition, undermining collective action and social solidarity in addressing societal issues.
Deep dives
The Professional Managerial Class (PMC)
The discussion centers on the concept of the Professional Managerial Class (PMC) and its historical significance. This class emerged in the early 20th century as professionals sought to improve working conditions and resist capitalist exploitation. Unlike traditional workers, PMC members do not own the means of production but have significant roles in managing and organizing labor. Their increasing influence has shifted from advocating for workers' rights to aligning more closely with capital, raising concerns about their current roles as managers rather than advocates.
Trauma Culture Defined
The term 'trauma culture' is introduced as a modern societal phenomenon where public sharing of personal trauma is becoming increasingly normative. It emphasizes how individuals frame their experiences through the lens of trauma to gain validation and authenticity in a social context. This culture has roots in the anti-psychiatry movement of the New Left, but its current iteration often commodifies trauma, reducing complex human experiences to performative narratives. The discussion critiques how this shift might obscure the broader social and political contexts of collective suffering.
The Personal vs. Collective Identity
A critical distinction is made between individual trauma narratives and collective struggles, particularly in the context of marginalized communities. Research indicates that children experiencing shared collective trauma, such as Palestinian youth, show resilience through their connection to larger narratives. This emphasizes the importance of community and identity over individual suffering, countering the trend of personalizing trauma. The dialogue suggests that a shift towards recognizing communal suffering could foster resilience and solidarity rather than isolating individuals.
Commodification and Marketization of Trauma
The conversation highlights the commodification of trauma, wherein individual stories of suffering are marketed for social validation and profit. This capitalist exploitation is evident in therapeutic practices and media portrayals, where personal traumas are packaged as consumable content. An illustrative example is the historical context of political figures grappling with mental health challenges, where previous stigma has transformed into public spectacle. Such dynamics raise questions about the authenticity of trauma narratives when they become intertwined with commercial interests.
Neoliberalism and Individual Responsibility
The discussion critiques neoliberalism’s impact on societal structures, particularly its emphasis on individualism and personal responsibility. As public institutions face austerity measures, responsibilities are increasingly shifted onto individuals, perpetuating a cycle of competition and dependency on privatized systems. This shift undermines collective action and solidarity while fostering an environment of isolation among individuals. By examining how these dynamics play out in educational settings and community practices, the conversation urges the need for a reevaluation of social practices and a return to collective responsibility for societal issues.
If you’d like to gain access to early release of full, ad-free episodes and support the podcast, consider becoming part of the pack over at patreon.com/howlinthewilderness. We are an independent production and rely on the support of listeners like you. Make a one-time contribution to http://paypal.me/brianjamessoul
HITW is hosted by depth counselor, writer and cultural activist Brian James: http://brianjames.ca
Check out my new book Traumadelic: Re-Visioning Psychedelic Therapy http://traumadelicbook.com
Catherine Liu (born 1964) is an American cultural theorist and author whose areas of research include Sinophone cinema, French literature, critical theory, identity politics, and visual arts. She is known for her critique of the professional–managerial class.
Her research and teaching focuses on the intellectual history and formation of cultural criticism, the history of the professional-managerial class, psychoanalytic theory, the political economy of cultural revolutions, and the work of the Frankfurt School and Walter Benjamin. She has also published on various topics in art criticism, museum history, and cultural politics.
Her most recent book published in 2021, Virtue Hoarders: The Case Against the Professional Managerial Class, is a polemical call to reject making a virtue out of taste and consumption habits.
