In 1922, a reverend and a choir singer were found dead under a tree with love letters. Tabloid reporters spread rumors about the case. The scandalous relationship between the reverend and Eleanor Mills is explored, along with witness accounts and the involvement of Jane Gibson. Frances Hall's highly publicized trial and Jane Gibson's credibility are discussed. The accused are eventually found not guilty.
The murder case of Reverend Edward Hall and Eleanor Mills in 1922 gained widespread attention due to scandalous details and extensive media coverage, highlighting the power of tabloid journalism in shaping public opinion.
The confession of Julius Baliog, claiming involvement in the murders and alleging a hired hitman, raises questions about the possible role of Francis Hall's family in attempting to eliminate the scandal surrounding the affair.
Deep dives
The Mysterious Murders of Reverend Edward Hall and Eleanor Mills
The podcast explores the infamous murders of Reverend Edward Hall and Eleanor Mills in 1922. The victims, who were involved in an alleged affair, were found dead together under a crab apple tree. The case garnered national attention, with scandalous details and extensive media coverage. Despite investigations and trials, no one was ever convicted of the murders. The podcast analyzes the various theories and explores the possibility of a hired hitman being involved.
The Trial and Acquittal of Francis Hall
The trial of Francis Hall, the wife of Reverend Edward Hall, and her brothers, Willie and Henry, for the murders is discussed. Despite public perception and suspicion, the jury returned a not guilty verdict for all three defendants. The case was a media spectacle, attracting countless reporters and creating a nationwide sensation. It delves into the role of tabloid journalism in shaping public opinion and the scandalous nature of the crimes.
The Allegations and Confessions Years Later
The podcast examines the confession of Julius Baliog, who claims to have been involved in the murders. Baliog alleges that he was hired to deliver money to hitmen who killed Reverend Hall and Eleanor Mills. Although his story lacks definitive evidence, it raises questions about the possible involvement of Francis Hall's family and their efforts to eliminate the scandal surrounding the affair.
The Legacy and Unsolved Mysteries
The episode concludes with the aftermath of the murders and the impact on the people involved. It discusses the lasting mystery surrounding the case and the inability to definitively solve it. The podcast raises doubts about the guilt or innocence of Frances Hall and explores the complex dynamics and motivations behind the killings.
On September 16, 1922, a reverend and a choir singer were found dead under a tree. Between their bodies was a stack of love letters. When police began investigating the murders, tabloid reporters did too, and rumors about the case began to spread quickly.
We have some exciting news – Criminal is going back on tour! We can’t wait to see you. Presale tickets are available at 12 pm ET today for Criminal Plus members. If you're not a member yet, you can sign up at thisiscriminal.com/plus. We'll post news and links for general sale tickets when they're available at thisiscriminal.com/live.
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, members-only merch, and more. Learn more and sign up here.